I've tried BabyBjorn bibs. They are not soft and would not fit around my 6 month old's neck. I've tried Aden and Anais bibs and they frayed after only a couple washes. I was able to buy a couple of these on clearance in a Target store where I live and they are a good value. They are not as heavy duty as the DEX bib which is my favorite but they get the job done. They can easily be rinsed off in the sink after each use and so far are holding up quite well. The only thing I would change about them is I wish they snapped on instead of Velcro.