Back in 2009 I bought the cheaper, all-cloth Target Home version of this and it lasted, although the hooks were pulling on the fabric on top and the shelves were snapped and a bit saggy. This was my fault as I tended to overload the thing with my socks, briefs, T-shirts, etc. I happened to come across this newer, sturdier looking organizer. While it costs more than the mid-range model and to get all six compartments you have to buy additional shelves, this will last at least 5 times as long! The hooks are not built in to the cloth but instead are hanger-like with much support and the plastic shelves are easy to put on and sturdy enough to not break. It's the same size as my older one but much better put together. I highly recommend this!