I love the Nantucket Collection as well! It's absolutely adorable! I do agree that the pillow is a light lime green, as mentioned before, but it does not bother me in the least. The alligators on the crib sheet are a little lighter, and the one on the blanket is as well. I think it's a great addition to the set, and will look great in the glider in our nursery! I ordered the 3 piece set, valance, blanket, and this alligator, and would not think about returning any of it!! Can't wait for our little guy to get here so he can enjoy it all as well!!
I guess pictures are deceiving. I thought that the alligator pillow would be like the little alligators on the mobile that we previously ordered. It looks nothing like that alligator! This pillow is very soft and made from microplush fleece material not regular fleece like I had anticipated. It is very soft and I still think my little boy will love it however it really doesn't match the bedding set in my opinion. It is a light lime green color not the apple greenish color I thought it would be. It looks like it would match the Bananafish Nantucket Blanket, [$] on this site, but doesn't really match the quilt, sheets, mobile, and bed skirt like I had hoped. I'm not returning it now since I already had to pay for shipping, however, if I had known this prior to ordering I probably would not have purchased it.