This is a great product. I just recently bought it in brown eyed girl and purple haze my eyes are blue it still looks great. Initially they go on very sheer and its almost like instant dissapointment but its buildable so keep packing the color on and you get good color saturation and a lot of sparkle! Very fun eyeshadow for going out or just adding some spice in your day. Also the packaging is simple but sturdy.
I always glance at these eyeshadows when I shop at Target, and the other day I finally decided to buy one. I have a few other Sonia Kashuk products that I really like so I figured what the heck. I purchased the Fair and Square quad, and I was a bit disappointed in the color pay off of these shadows. I'm hoping they show up more pigmented if applied wet. The other qualm I have over this product is the wear. I wore it several times with and without eyelid primer, and though when I wore primer the wear of the shadow improved, it still didn't last me all day. It's a bit annoying to have to fix your make up midday.
Also, the lightest shade is VERY sparkly. Not necessarily a bad thing, but I wasn't expecting it to have so much glitter, since I bought this to use as a neutral every day palette.
So is it a horrible product? No. But I've definitely used better eyeshadows. If you have the money and feel like trying this, go on ahead! Keep in mind that it's not the best out there.