So far, I am pleased with this stone. I have only used it a couple of times, so I cannot report on its longevity, and that is why I have not given it a full five stars. I used to have a smaller 13" round stone, which broke in half spontaneously in the oven after a couple of years of use, also purchased from Target. This stone is much more versatile, being much larger and thicker. However, you are paying for it, as it is about three times the price of the small stone I used to have. I should also note that the stone itself is half an inch thick, but has riser feet (all molded with the stone as one piece) of half an inch, giving the one inch thickness that is reported. [..]
I love this pizza pan. I got it off my wedding registry and have used it two or three times already. It makes a large pizza, which is the perfect size for us to eat off of and have leftovers. The quality is great, and my pizzas have turned out great. I'd definitely recommend it.