10.5" Stoneware Reactive Glaze Dinner Plate - Hearth & Hand™ with Magnolia

These plates are undeniably beautiful—their design has a charming, rustic appeal, with a purposely uneven shape that gives them a handmade, artisanal look. The subtle imperfections in the form make them visually interesting and unique. However, it's clear they're mass-produced, as every plate has the same uniform unevenness. While the design adds character, it also means they don’t stack perfectly unless you line them up just right, which can be a bit annoying if you like to line things up perfectly like I do. Unfortunately, like many other reviews have noted, these plates chip far too easily. Despite their aesthetic appeal, the durability leaves something to be desired. After just a few uses, I noticed small chips on the edges, which is disappointing for something so lovely. If you’re looking for plates that are more than just decorative, you may want to keep that in mind.

Wanted to love these and I do love them but they are NOT scratch resistant. I have not had them long and every plate is scratched from normal use.

I would not get this shipped to your home, ever. I ordered these dinner plates, one set of 4 plates and when it came 2 of the plates were broken. I reported it to Target and they sent me another set free of charge and that package came broken as well. I’m extremely disappointed. Might as well but Walmarts version of these.

These plates are perfect. The color matches my decor and always like stoneware products.

I bought a set of eight of these, along with salad and desert plates, bowls, mugs, etc. four years ago. They have held up well until I recently chipped two of the dinner plates. So, I decided to order another set of four dinner plates when they finally became available again. They arrived and ARE WAAAAAY SMALLER than the original dinner plates o purchased. Seriously?!!!! They aren’t salad plate size but they are closer to that than dinner plate size. What garbage!!! I used to love Hearth and Hand but it seems they have gone the way of everyone else once they become rich and famous. Sad.

Love these dishes! Have had some for a few months and just purchased a couple more!

Echoing a previous review that the size and weight has changed. We had a full set that, yes, chips quite easily. We started purchasing the set maybe around 2019 - 2020? I recently purchased a few new ones to replace the ones that had chipped. They are absolutely not the same size or weight that they used to be. It’s noticeable and now whenever we stack them, we’ll have to make a point to stack the new ones last or it will throw off the balance of the entire thing. Consistency really struggles here. For reference, the left hand plate in my photo is an older run, the right hand plate is the new one.

Love the style but they chip way too easily.

These plates are absolutely beautiful and of high-quality as well. You can tell just by holding them that they are not cheap and flimsy. I can’t believe what a low price they were.

Absolutely in love with the plates. Gorgeous and great quality!

My husband and I love these! They’re super pretty. They are a bit heavy but in a high quality way. I’m happy we bought them!

I love these dishes. They are beautiful and go so easily with different decor. The size and shape is amazing and each dish is unique.

They are cute but horrible! They chip so easy. My last set of dishes I had for 12 years and they never once chipped. I just wanted to switch up the dishes and bought these! DONT waste your money!

Like the uniqueness of these plates. I also have the smaller salad plates.

These plates are a very beautiful gray color but not dark gray. A cross between off white and gray. We changed out our entire kitchen collection with these pieces and are very happy. Almost like a concrete look

Love my new plates. Color is great and the shape is cool

Love the look, the feel and the weight. They would be PERFECT BUT they chip sooooo easily. I’d love to blame my kids but even stacking them in the cupboard can cause the edges to chip and crack.

I absolutely love this dishes.

I love these plates.

The plates are great! Love them. Nice, heavy fell and look great!