Really nicely made shoe - good quality. I did not give 5 stars because I bought this in sizes 1.5 and 2 to see what would be the better fit and the sizing seems totally random! The 1.5 were much bigger than the size 2.
Ordered these for my son for a school performance that asked him to dress up. He wanted to wear a suit with black shoes. These satisfied him well and while I questioned their comfort - he did not express any issues. The laces are plastic and odd to tie - I can see they would wear quickly if this shoe was worn more than a few times - that's the reason for the 4 stars. But 5 starts for price and fitting our need.
My son just tried these on and they fit great! He really liked them, too, which is a bonus! They loosened up enough and were wide enough for his wide foot and high arch, a definite plus for his foot shape. Overall, a great purchase!