I'd give it zero stars if I could but that's not an option. Applies black but almost watered out so make sure you shake it real good before you use it. I put this eyeliner on with eye primer and finished with setting spray after my makeup was done. That was about 9:30am and it is now currently 1:35pm in the afternoon and the eyeliner has turned into that faded gray-blue color...yah know that old faded tattoo color on old people?By the end of the day it will start to crumble off. I know because this is my 5th time using it this week. I haven't even tried the gym with it on but that'd be a laugh because it doesn't even hold up with normal day wear. I am not being a troll this is just the honest truth from someone who is an eyeliner junky! Skip this eyeliner. It's not worth the $6.99.