Allison - 15 days ago, Verified purchaser
I got the extra firm and love it. I did have the chance to feel the pillow in store first, so I chose based on that. I’m not sure I would truly call it extra firm—I think someone would really wanted a firm pillow may be dissatisfied. I like my pillows to provide a lot of support but still be soft when I actually put my head on it. It doesn’t turn to flat mush overnight like lots of other pillows that start feeling thick. At this price, I will be buying more to replace my other pillows and donating the old ones. I’m very excited to find a nice big, but inexpensive pillow because it’ll be great for the decorative sham pillows to give them a “full” look.