EasterBlack-owned or founded brands at TargetGroceryClothing, Shoes & AccessoriesBabyHomeFurnitureKitchen & DiningOutdoor Living & GardenToysElectronicsVideo GamesMovies, Music & BooksSports & OutdoorsBeautyPersonal CareHealthPetsHousehold EssentialsArts, Crafts & SewingSchool & Office SuppliesParty SuppliesLuggageGift IdeasGift CardsClearanceTarget New ArrivalsTarget Finds#TargetStyleTop DealsTarget Circle DealsWeekly AdShop Order PickupShop Same Day DeliveryRegistryRedCardTarget CircleFind Stores

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Light Buttery Spread - 15oz

I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Light Buttery Spread - 15oz - 2 of 4I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Light Buttery Spread - 15oz - 3 of 4I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Light Buttery Spread - 15oz - 4 of 4
I Can't Believe It's Not Butter! Light Buttery Spread - 15oz - 1 of 4
$4.29 when purchased online
Target Online store #3991

About this item

Related Categories

Guests are saying

The product has received mixed feedback from guests, with many expressing disappointment over a recent recipe change that affects taste and melting properties. While some guests appreciate its lower calorie count and versatility in cooking, others miss the original flavor and texture. The spreadability is often praised, making it a convenient option for various dishes. Overall, it remains a popular choice for those seeking a healthier alternative to butter.
    Summary created by AI from text of reviews reflecting recent feedback provided across different star ratings (includes incentivized reviews)
    3.6 out of 5 stars with 1341 reviews
    quality: 4 out of 5
    taste: 3.83 out of 5
    value: 4.17 out of 5
    100% would recommend
    3 recommendations

    Velvety Soft.

    4 out of 5 stars
    sonyar53_3538 - 29 days ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    The texture is very velvety and soft. Smells like butter. Great packaging to store away. Overall love this product for cooking. Ingredients are good. Effectiveness 👍🏽👍🏽
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Not to bad

    3 out of 5 stars
    harrietd21_333 - 1 month ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    Okay once it has been melted but has an artificial taste and texture otherwise - would still buy it again as it’s a good healthy alternative to normal butter.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Aftertaste

    2 out of 5 stars
    Johnny - 4 months ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    The first taste is fabulous, just like butter. But soon, as the product melts in the mouth, a musty aftertaste emerges. Is it from the plastic container? Or one of the ingredients? I don't know, but it's not subtle. Wish it wasn't there, but I taste what I taste.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Absolutely Delicious and Healthy

    5 out of 5 stars
    Tiger - 6 months ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    It's very delicious and healthy! Love it on the toasted bread with honey and a nice vanilla latte drink!
    Did you find this review helpful?

    I can't believe they've ruined it

    1 out of 5 stars
    Jane - 1 year ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    Very disappointed with new Light I can't believe it's not butter. The taste is not as good and has far more calories. Old one 180 per 100g new one 252 per 100g. What is the improvement? As I couldn't always get this I would stock up when I saw it for sale. I won't bother anymore I will just get a supermarket brand instead and save some money.
    1 guest found this review helpful. Did you?

    Absolutely awful now

    1 out of 5 stars
    Snoz - 1 year ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    Used it before and found ok bought 2 tubs and used both falls off knife doesn’t melt couldn’t even dissolve it with washing up liquid when cleaning out tub to recycle
    Did you find this review helpful?

    New recipe is awful

    1 out of 5 stars
    Frankie - 1 year ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    I cant believe its not butter light used to be my go to for low calorie spread that acted in the same way and tasted as good as full fat versions but since something in the recipe changed I will no longer be buying it. The old version used to melt just like real butter but whatever change has been made means that it goes soft but it doesn't melt into toast or mashed potatoes or anything else you put it on hot. The taste is not the same either. So disappointed, we used to make special trips specifically to buy I cant believe its not butter but we won't be any more. I definitely can believe its not butter
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Light

    5 out of 5 stars
    Fullau - 1 year ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    I bought this this week and I can believe it tastes so good and lighter
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Changed for the Worst!

    1 out of 5 stars
    JayD - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    I can't Believe It's Not Butter Light used to be my favourite 'healthy' spread but without any indication of doing so, they have changed the recipe and now it no longer melts! This is despite the tubs still saying 2Spread with it, Melt it, Blend it & G;laze it!" This new version is absolutely awful to use, especially if you want to melt it onto toast or vegetables. So sad when companies do this - and very wrong not to mark the packaging alerting buyers there has been a change. So I won't buy it anymore - and can't recommend that anyone else does!
    Did you find this review helpful?

    I cant believe its not butter light

    1 out of 5 stars
    Chris07887 - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    Has this changed? Taste smell recipe all different recently. It doesn't even melt on toast, whats in this?? Before I would rated this 5 stars!
    Did you find this review helpful?

    I can't believe they are allowed to call it that

    1 out of 5 stars
    Chef Louie - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    Don't know who all these people are that are writing positive reviews. Clearly they have NEVER tasted real butter. Or maybe this company is paying people to write reviews. This product tastes NOTHING anywhere near resembling butter. Bland, chemical taste and melts in your hands right out of the fridge even before you get the wrapper all the way off. Someone should sue the manufacturer for selling this product.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Where can I buy the LARGE tub of the light version

    5 out of 5 stars
    Cleopatra - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    I live in San Diego and only have the LIgHt 15oz version. Have you stopped making the large tub?
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Great product, wish it came in larger quantity

    4 out of 5 stars
    txmom - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    We love this "butter" and use it almost daily. The only complaint I have it that I wish it was available in the larger tub like the Original ICBINB. We have a large family and go through that tiny container fast. We would love to buy it in bulk!
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Wow! Couldn't eat without this product.

    5 out of 5 stars
    Henry sand - 2 years ago
    originally posted on icantbelieveitsnotbutter.com
    Image
    This butter is so amazing you really can't believe It's Not Butter I put it on crackers and flatbreads you could even add it into recipes you wouldn't know the difference it is so delicious and in a world will people complain I just wanted to give a positive review and feedback to the company that this is an amazing product and I appreciate it. Thank you
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Just No

    1 out of 5 stars
    nicolef1008 - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    Why would i want to eat fake butter when butter is real? What kind of alternate universe is this where we are told to eat plastic butter? Butter is delicious.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Similar to the pricier Flora.

    4 out of 5 stars
    jackiedas - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    Similar to the pricier Flora. To save money, I looked around for a less expensive, lower-fat margarine than the Flora Light I've been using for years. The only difference in this product is the packaging.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    It's not for consumption

    2 out of 5 stars
    bayroyalty - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    I found out that the name of this brand's products are 100% accurate. It's absolutely NOT butter. They originally made it to help plump up turkeys and they weren't able to tolerate it so they didn't continue with giving it to them. They put yellow food coloring on it and gave it to humans. It doesn't even melt on any flame or hot food. It's not something I can eat or imagine serving again.
    Did you find this review helpful?

    Only butter I buy.

    5 out of 5 stars
    - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    Only butter I buy. My boyfriend can't handle dairy so this is what I use for my cooking. Tastes great and I actually prefer it over actual butter!
    2 guests found this review helpful. Did you?

    I really like this

    5 out of 5 stars
    samanthanicolef - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    I really like this butter and just like it’s name, I really can’t believe it’s not butter!Even this light version doesn’t taste any different to me so why not ya know! Super yummy I use on everything!
    Did you find this review helpful?

    I use this on

    5 out of 5 stars
    kayciep1_5390 - 3 years ago
    originally posted on influenster.com
    Image
    I use this on a daily basis. It’s not the same as regular butter, no. But if you’re looking for a better, healthier option to regular butter… THIS is it!! Works well in many ways - to butter toasts, sauté veggies, all general cooking needs. Hands down, a go-to for me!
    2 guests found this review helpful. Did you?

    Get top deals, latest trends, and more.

    Privacy policy

    Footer

    About Us

    About TargetCareersNews & BlogTarget BrandsBullseye ShopSustainability & GovernancePress CenterAdvertise with UsInvestorsAffiliates & PartnersSuppliersTargetPlus

    Help

    Target HelpReturnsTrack OrdersRecallsContact UsFeedbackAccessibilitySecurity & FraudTeam Member Services

    Stores

    Find a StoreClinicPharmacyTarget OpticalMore In-Store Services

    Services

    Target Circle™Target Circle™ CardTarget Circle 360™Target AppRegistrySame Day DeliveryOrder PickupDrive UpFree 2-Day ShippingShipping & DeliveryMore Services
    PinterestFacebookInstagramXYoutubeTiktokTermsCA Supply ChainPrivacyCA Privacy RightsYour Privacy ChoicesInterest Based AdsHealth Privacy Policy