Mixing recollections with a supernatural Hamlet-inspired theme, her watercolor-tinged illustrations add a wonderfully ethereal layer to an already nuanced offering. Defying genre boundaries, Thrash has proven herself a capable memoirist able to pinpoint her own pivotal life moments, turn them into art, and take risks with conventions. Nearly all characters present as white. A thoughtful and compelling exploration of adolescence.
--Kirkus Reviews (starred review)
The author/illustrator looks back on her teen years with a pitch-perfect blend of caustic humor, melancholy, and tenderness, depicting her younger self's frustration with her wealthy, ignorant cohorts and her growing understanding of her own privilege...Thrash boldly mixes memoir and fiction for a perceptive exploration of her past that will resonate profoundly with readers of Honor Girl
, Laurie Halse Anderson and Emily Carroll's Speak: The Graphic Novel
, and Katie Green's Lighter Than My Shadow
--School Library Journal (starred review)
This should resonate with readers looking for unusual realistic fiction that doesn't shy away from difficult themes.
In a closing note Thrash comments on the facts at the core of her tale--privilege, loneliness, coming out, and yes, a lost cat--and how she reconciles memoir with ghost story. Readers who met Maggie in her Camp Bellflower summer will be happy to see her work her way toward acceptance.
--Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books
Thrash's bone-dry observational humor stays provocative...and her rugged draftsmanship and solid toolbox of visual storytelling techniques can handle any emotional register with honesty: teen ennui; cold exchanges with her parents; angry jabs at the rich, bigoted white boys at her school; and the chilling dreams that haunt Maggie's nights.
Simultaneously a coming-of-age tale about a lonely teenager and a ghost story, Thrash's spooky storytelling is a clever tool to contextualize family and identity.
--Shelf Awareness for Readers
[Thrash's] original, challenging, tragicomic story forges new territory in the world of queer storytelling.