Rolling Stone - 3.5 stars out of 5 -- "These stark songs are meditative, lonely, and stubbornly isolated, like spending 45 minutes petting a cat. A static search for comfort." Spin - "[A] track like 'Nobody' retains the meticulous approach that's worked so well for DeMarco in the past, playing around without sacrificing sophistication." NME (Magazine) - 4 stars out of 5 -- "[T]his is the funkiest record of Mac DeMarco's career, with its serene charm and more introspective songs proving its creator now cares less about what will play well on the festival stages and more about letting us inside his head." Clash (Magazine) - "On 'All Of Our Yesterdays', classic DeMarco shines through as he once again proves his ability to transport listeners to a secluded lakeside with rays shimmering between the leaves."