Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

Horrible product, was lifting/flaking as drying. When I curled my eyelashes to put on mascara the whole line came off in one piece on one eye and half lifted on other one. I had to start eyes over without any. Complete waste of money. I wish I would’ve looked at the reviews.

I've used this for years and it is great! Hope they never discontinue this!

I have used this product for years but this new bottle is awful. Very streaky and runny. Reapplied 3 times within 4 hours and this eyeliner still cracks and peels. It’s wish I would have read all the bad reviews before purchasing. Will not purchase again. Don’t know waste your money.

This product has changed so much. I have been using this eyeliner for years and years. Now it skips and peels off like a sticker. There are flakes on my face throughout the day. Totally embarrassing to wear. Take this off the market or revert back to your old product.

What have you done to this product?? I’ve been using it for over 20 years, I used recommended to everyone! But in the last year, something has changed. It is very difficult to apply because there is not any ink in the bottle. I’ve purchased several different bottles and even have alternated between the black and the dark brown thinking maybe just the bottles were just defective but after so much time giving so many chances, now I believe the entire product altogether is a scam. You’ve done something different, you’re skimping on your ink, and you’re charging tons of money for this product. I’m Extremely disappointed and I no longer recommend this product to anyone. It’s a false product and you should take it off the line instead of degrading it and putting on the shelves while still charging insane prices for it. That’s incredibly poor & dishonest marketing.

Its easy to use, I learned how to do eyeliner with this. Long lasting aswell.

This eyeliner is waterproof and tear-proof, but can be fully removed without scrubbing and scraping off at the end of the day.

I like this brush applicator better than the felt tip pen version, as it creates a fine line with a light hand that will flow easily into a thicker line towards the outer eye. It does take a bit of practice to get the feel of the brush. But hands down, it's the longest lasting, stays-put all day liner I've tried yet. The formula dries fast, and you want just enough ink on the brush to draw a smooth line, too much and it will cake up and crumble when it dries. It's harder to use after about a month, as the ink gets a bit clumpy in the bottle from being exposed to open air, but a few rapid pumps of the applicator in and out of the bottle will churn it up and make it usable again.

Been using for years. Stays put all day. I agree with others, original was better, but still use it. PLEASE bring back the taupe shade. Loved it for when need a more natural look....better for us baby boomers!

I have used this product for over 20 years. This latest one I bought is awful. It peels and I have to keep dipping the brush to complete my line. So sad the formula has changed. It used to be the best.

Applied eyeliner like usual. When I applied my mascara the eyeliner started peeling off. . It all came off at once .

Unfortunately this product has changed & it is horrible! I have used this product for 20 years (since high school) & it now is BAD. It's very spotty, takes about 9 dips in the bottle to apply & complete my eyeliner application. A new bottle currently applies like a half dried out marker. I have read some of most recent reviews & they all are saying the same thing. I have even tried purchasing it from different stores over the past year & they all have been the same. They are selling a faulty product at this point & I'm very disappointed in Maybelline. The only reason I keep trying is because I REALLY loved this eyeliner & keep hoping for the best. PLEASE, please, please go back to the old formula! I feel that they are making a lot of money on a bad product. They have to be aware of this d/t the poor rating on this website. At this point, they should stop manufacturing is or rectify the problem.

Reading all these reviews, I would never have bought another bottle of this liner. I’ve used this for years. Something happened to the last 2 bottles I purchased. I thought maybe something was wrong with the first bottle, so I bought a second. Both were the same, flaking off after a short time. I loved it because of the fine brush and waterproof factor. After a couple of hours, you could actually peel it off because it left gaps. Don’t know what happened to your formula, but not the same.

the brush was changed and it’s to thick to get a good wing and also a lot flimsier than previously. I like the formula but it’s an inconvenience to have to bring around my own applicator. The product itself is fairly drying so at the beginning of application it’s great but throughout the day it does need to be touched up because the cracking so my solution was to use a black eyeshadow over it to make sure it stays and if it cracks (And depending on ur skin texture and ur facial expressions it will) there will still be coverage in those places. Overall you can probably find one better for a bit more but for the price it’s decent and gets the job done

Same thing ... using this product and loved this product for YEARS then suddenly doesn't perform the same ... runny, thin, have to apply several coats. MUCH different than before. So sad.