Maybelline Ultra Liner Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

I have used this product for over 20 years. This latest one I bought is awful. It peels and I have to keep dipping the brush to complete my line. So sad the formula has changed. It used to be the best.

Applied eyeliner like usual. When I applied my mascara the eyeliner started peeling off. . It all came off at once .

Unfortunately this product has changed & it is horrible! I have used this product for 20 years (since high school) & it now is BAD. It's very spotty, takes about 9 dips in the bottle to apply & complete my eyeliner application. A new bottle currently applies like a half dried out marker. I have read some of most recent reviews & they all are saying the same thing. I have even tried purchasing it from different stores over the past year & they all have been the same. They are selling a faulty product at this point & I'm very disappointed in Maybelline. The only reason I keep trying is because I REALLY loved this eyeliner & keep hoping for the best. PLEASE, please, please go back to the old formula! I feel that they are making a lot of money on a bad product. They have to be aware of this d/t the poor rating on this website. At this point, they should stop manufacturing is or rectify the problem.

Reading all these reviews, I would never have bought another bottle of this liner. I’ve used this for years. Something happened to the last 2 bottles I purchased. I thought maybe something was wrong with the first bottle, so I bought a second. Both were the same, flaking off after a short time. I loved it because of the fine brush and waterproof factor. After a couple of hours, you could actually peel it off because it left gaps. Don’t know what happened to your formula, but not the same.

the brush was changed and it’s to thick to get a good wing and also a lot flimsier than previously. I like the formula but it’s an inconvenience to have to bring around my own applicator. The product itself is fairly drying so at the beginning of application it’s great but throughout the day it does need to be touched up because the cracking so my solution was to use a black eyeshadow over it to make sure it stays and if it cracks (And depending on ur skin texture and ur facial expressions it will) there will still be coverage in those places. Overall you can probably find one better for a bit more but for the price it’s decent and gets the job done

Same thing ... using this product and loved this product for YEARS then suddenly doesn't perform the same ... runny, thin, have to apply several coats. MUCH different than before. So sad.

I’ve been using ultra liner for almost a decade - it is one of the only liquid liners on the market that has a bristle brush and not a felt tip style brush. I can’t believe how thin the new brush is!! How are we supposed to apply makeup with three bristles?? I’ve noticed makeup companies are starting to cut corners big time to make more profit, like no longer including applicator pads in compacts, or sharpeners for brow pencils, but the downgrade of this new brush is so ridiculous it’s comical! Time to search for a replacement!

I have been using this for over 20 years because it was the best liquid eyeliner on the market. All of a sudden the formula is thin and messy and the brush is so thin it barely picks up product. Whatever changes made is not working. Change it back.

I’ve been using this product for 15+ years always been my go to! I just purchased two bottles because I assumed the first was defective. Turns out they are both terrible. They do no go on solid like it use to. The product is semi sheer and the line is super messy looking. Super disappointed. I highly recommend bringing back to original. This “new” version is absolutely terrible.

I have used Maybelline ultra eye liner waterproof for 20 yrs +. For the past 3 months I have purchased this eyeliner more than usual. Thinking I just got an old batch, because the eyeliner is dry, not highly pigmented and doesn't go on very smooth plus the brush bristles are thin. Very different from the product I have used for years. After reading several reviews I understand I'm not alone in having the same issues with this "new formula ". So disappointed and dissatisfied with this product. Please change it back to the formula that was easy to apply and wasn't dry .

Product goes on easily and precisely. Stays in place even when your eyes tear up. Easy to remove.

The brush is so soft it doesn't hold shape enough for a nice solid line (thin or thick) does not apply smoothly. Leaves gaps in line

Been wearing this for years. Over the last few years the packaging has been falling apart. Every single one I have purchased in the last 5 or 6 years has become an utter mess. The inside of the container comes apart. This happened the other day and the entire interior part came out when I opened it - liquid eyeliner went everywhere. It was a horrible mess :/ I noticed this problem began when they stopped putting a separate cap on the bottle with the wand placed next to the bottle in the package. And what happened to the “Slate” color??

Have used for decades! Would not choose any other!

This has been my one and only go to eyeliner for years! It’s the best and always stays in place. Although I cannot find it anywhere. Please say it has not been discontinued?