Michie - 6 months ago, Verified purchaser
Let me preface this by saying I took one star away because of the waxy, low-level chocolate, but that's to be expected from Nabisco, sadly. However the ratio of chocolate to peanut butter to cookie is nice. I actually have never had plain Nutter Butter Cookies, so I can't compare the 2. However, these cookies are crisp, almost like a sugar wafer, and the combination of everything is like a light and crispy Reese's Peanut Butter Cup. The box contains 12 cookies and I dare you to stop at the suggested serving of 2.