Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner - Intense Black - 0.016 fl oz - Ulta Beauty

I loved the pigement of this the first use. The second use it wasnt as dark. Every use it has rubbed off on the upper part of my eyelid. I was recommended this by an ulta employee when i said i wanted a liner for dramatic wings. I went back to ask another employee for a new recommendation and they suggested this same one. Im very disappointed in this liner.

I've tried several liquid eye liners and this is one that I keep going back to. I wear contact lenses and find that some eyeliners do irritate my eyes. This is not one of them. In fact, it's fairly easy to use and stays put all day. I don't think I've ever had to reapply. Love it!

This was not the product for me. My eyes are not dry enough for the liner to adhere to my lash line.

I love their formula and its vibrancy but HATE and I mean HATE their felt tip/applicator. My first one I thought was a defective one. After 3 days of having it, it dried out. The second one was after a week. I never left the cap off, the felt tip is terrible. They need to change to a different felt or a brush tip. SERIOUSLY, they really need to do something about it because their color selection and pigmentation is great but what gets them low ratings is the felt tip that is horrendous.

This is way too expensive to dry out as fast as it does. I'm starting to question if there's any decent pen eyeliners out there because after a week of use, they just stop working.

Ive tried almost every single liquid liner on the market from low end to high end and nothing beats my stila waterproof liner. I hope they never discontinue this because I will crumble. I cannot live without this liner.

First of all, I usually love all things Stila! This liner has a great color and wont move once you get it on. I've had it for a few months and haven't used it daily. The brush/pen gives zero color now. I've had others open longer that can still be used.

I used to work at Ulta about 6 years ago and this was my holy grail. I would recommend it to everyone. I recently started getting back into my makeup and bought a few of these. They all started drying up within a month and i would at most do my eyeliner twice a week. The formula is not the same. At first its great but after about 8 uses the color wont come out pigmented. Super faded. For the pricepoint thats kind of unacceptable. No matter how many time I retrace the line the color will not come out.

I was initially really excited about this product the found out upon delivery, a smaller than expected item for eyeliner about half or 1/4 of a pencil and gave me a reaction, causing an eye infection of some sort I have to flush my eyes out often and I have to put a hot compress on my eyes to drain the bumps

With a little primer underneath, this ain't going ANYWHERE on your face. Striking and defined, this is the definition of eyeliner in my opinion.

I used to love this eyeliner as it would go on smooth and last all day. Something has changed as the product won't come out and it's difficult to use. I tried a few different purchases and the same issue persists. I'll be switching to something else.

Maybe it's my skin, but I can't get this to go on. It's like it's dried out, but when I blot I see it's working. Gave it to my daughter, maybe she'll have some luck. I usually get black with the shorter tip and love it.

I got the Smokey Quartz color and it is a struggle to get product out, even when first opened and I have left the component lying on its side and upside down. I like the color (I typically wear matte black) and it does last all day, but it's so hard to get product out and application is kind of difficult. I have been using liquid eyeliner for a long time and I would not recommend or repurchase this because of the application.

I was impressed the moment I realized this liner gives a deep black, slightly glossy finish that makes my eyes look more defined and "popping." The tip is very flexible, so it's easy to create the wing shape I like. The formula is excellent: it dries quickly, so I can clip my eyelashes right after applying without worrying about smudging. It's also waterproof and sweat-proof, which is a must for me living in a high-humidity climate. But one time, the tip dried out and barely released any product, I'm not sure why. But a few weeks later, the ink flow came back and it performed perfectly again. Overall, I'll definitely repurchase

This one seems the same as the Mac version. Transparent brown and layering coats erases old ones like a marker board.

The first use was ok. After that its a total battle to get it on. I'm throwing mine away now after the fourth use.

I have used stilla for years and always had a positive experience until recently. I purchased it not even a month ago and it's already running out. I now have the Mac liquid eyeliner and it works SO much better and lasts way longer. Do not waste your money on this!

I hate this eyeliner it is so streaky, I have to over it several times and its definitely not "waterproof"

The best eyeliner ever. Goes on easy ,stays on doesn't smear and also is removed with wipes very well

It was ok, I guess. It worked decently enough, and I liked the felt tip that didn't end up fraying. However, it was hard to fix any mistakes because the tip would rub off the eyeliner that was already there. It also dried up fairly quickly compared to other liners I've owned. Wasn't terrible, but wouldn't buy again.