HappyCamper - 5 months ago, Verified purchaser
Okay, so first thing's first, there are half sizes (I did not know that when I bought my pair), they're just after the list of whole sizes in the drop-down menu. I know, weird placement. So before you hit the checkout button on that 9 or 10, check after the whole sizes to see if there's a 9.5. Secondly, the sizing: reading the reviews left me very unsure of whether the shoe ran big or small. I'm normally anywhere from an 8-9 in most brands. In Target brands, specifically A New Day, I wear a 7.5. Point is, I bought an 8 and they fit really well, so if you know your A New Day Size, I advise sizing up a half size. Also, I have pretty flat feet and I didn't feel like I was spilling over the sides of the shoe at all.
Lastly, the shoes aren't going to take you to any new heights, but one reviewer was right in saying that the lack of an incline on the shoe can feel awkward initially. I'm used to 4 inch heels, and these threw me off a little, so just keep that in mind. Other than that, it's a REALLY cute shoe and this raffia style sandal goes for a lot more at most retailers. So, if you're on the fence, I say go for it!