10.75" Tilley Stoneware Dinner Plate - Threshold™

These have been our go-to plates for over 6 years and they were great, until they weren't. Over time, I've had to replace a few dinner plates because they've broken. I would give them a higher rating but I've had to replace 4-5 plates in the last year alone. I just bought one last week that broke in half as we put in the cupboard after the dishwasher. One had a spiral crack. I'm not sure what has happened in the manufacturing in the last couple years, but they are poorer quality. I no longer recommend these expensive “disposable plates”.

Never received this order

Get these while you can, they just went on clearance for $3 and the colors as well as design is very beautiful and modern. Nice thick material so they are a bit on the heavier side.

I love them, beautifully made n heavy. It’s. 10/10. People say they chipped, don’t order online. Do curbside all of mine are in excellent condition

Ordered 4. Two came broken. I would think they would have packaged plates more carefully.

Color is a lighter gray than the photo. Not brown/gray…just gray. Idk why Target is afraid of (truly) warmer toned colors with their products. Blah. Not as pictured. Will be returning.

One plate arrived broken, it was not the color I wanted.

It's a plate. It's a nice heavy plate and nice color and seems to be of good quality. I like them.

Rims on plates CHIP EASILY! Not to mention if your dishwasher tunes are nice wide…theses will not fit properly. I’m still using what’s left of mine (3 sets) after 4 years…minus 10 salad plates).

I've had these plates (and the rest of the set) for about 3 years now, and not a single one has broken. I came back to leave a review after I dropped one from 5 feet off the ground, and there wasn't a scratch on it after. My guests always say they love the lip on the edge of the plates which is both a nice look and practical in helping get food on your fork. The other reviews are correct in that the color and design did slightly change. The new ones are more gray and the edges are slightly more rounded. I have a mix of the old ones (like the picture listed) and the new ones and I don't mind that they aren't exactly the same as stoneware can vary anyway.

Great looking stoneware, but they changed the look/color at some point, or they’re made with varying glazes so they can look *very* different though still be the same model…

These are a family favorite. The go to plate! Easy to handle easy to clean and doesn’t slip.

We really wanted to upgrade our plates with our recent move and these were perfect. I’ve seen this style in a lot of different places and they match our aesthetic perfectly.

Good plate, but they are different than the same plate from a year ago. I broke a plate and needed a replacement. The store version and one I ordered online both don’t match the set I already have. Lighter gray, less speckled. Now I have to replace all of my dishes if I want to have more than three large plates.

Color is nothing like photo. Light gray, NOT brown.

we love the feel of these plates.they are a beautiful color and nice size. added bonus, which is hard to know buying online.. they don't make a horrible sound if the fork slides across it. whew!

Looks nothing like the pictures on here. Light grey plates with no brown tones whatsoever. Returning

I ordered a set of 6 of these thinking they’re brown or darker in color but they turned out to be gray??? So I cancelled my order but I think the quality is good. It just didn’t look as advertised

It’s a nice design and a pretty color but the plate itself is a little heavy

We love the color and how aesthetically pleasing these dishes are! We got the whole set