Painted in Suspicion - by Crystal Caudill (Paperback)

Book Synopsis

She is determined to prove her worth. He is determined to prove his love.

Flossie Gibson is determined to prove women can thrive without marriage. Capable and caring, she has built a pottery business that offers widows a way to support themselves. But not everyone in Gilded Age Cincinnati approves of such innovations, and Flossie finds herself on the receiving end of pressure from competitors, intimidation from labor unions, and even vandals that threaten to shut down her business and dash her dreams.

Mortimer Stephens anticipates becoming an eventual partner at Gibson Stove Works, but that can only happen if he keeps Mr. Gibson happy. When a labor strike leads to threats against the Gibson family and Mortimer's controversial opinions put him at odds with his employer, Mortimer is reassigned to work with Flossie and protect her from whoever is determined to destroy her pottery.

Flossie wants nothing to do with the man who stabbed her in the back years ago, but Mortimer seeks to restore their friendship and convince her that perhaps marriage isn't such a terrible idea after all. Together, they will discover that the most beautiful creations are formed in the crucible of crisis and held together by the bonds of grace.

Review Quotes

"A charming blend of romance, mystery, and history has free rein in this installment of Crystal Caudill's The Art of Love & Danger series. Caudill's award-winning storytelling draws readers in and doesn't let them go until the last page is turned. Painted in Suspicion offers a glimpse into Gilded Age Cincinnati--both the virtuous and the villainous. Be prepared to enjoy the ride, but pay attention, because you won't want to miss a clue."--Elizabeth T. Renich, author of A Worthy Risk (7/16/2026 12:00:00 AM)

"Crystal Caudill delivers another great story rich in historical detail, page-turning suspense, and sigh-worthy romance. Her spunky heroine and steady, faithful hero balance each other out perfectly, and the spiritual truths woven throughout are both a challenge and a reminder as we live out our faith in Christ."--D'Ann Mateer, author of Playing By Heart (7/16/2026 12:00:00 AM)

"Crystal Caudill has done it again. With crisp, compelling prose and the perfect blend of suspense, romance, and faith, Painted in Suspicion kept me eagerly turning pages late into the night. Flossie's journey challenged my assumptions about strength and independence, ultimately revealing the beauty of a God-centered partnership where our gifts can flourish alongside love, marriage, and family."--Heather Tabers, Selah Award-winning author of Their Burden to Bear (7/16/2026 12:00:00 AM)

"Friends to enemies to lovers? Yes, please! With a spunky heroine who is determined not to marry and a devoted, protective so-called enemy who proves himself time and again to be her worthy hero with a heart of gold, what could go wrong? Painted in Suspicion is a faith-filled, heartfelt tale of healing and true love. Fans of Karen Witemeyer and Elizabeth Camden will devour this latest must-read mystery from the talented Crystal Caudill!"--Grace Hitchcock, award-winning author of To Win a Wager (7/16/2026 12:00:00 AM)

"Rich in history, romance, and suspense, Crystal Caudill's latest release snags readers from its first line and holds them until its last. With faith woven throughout as effortlessly as clay is wielded by a potter, this story beautifully depicts how God shapes us, loves us, and speaks truth over us. Painted in Suspicion will delight readers and leave them with a happy sigh."--Susan L. Tuttle, author of the Treasures of Halstead Manor series (7/16/2026 12:00:00 AM)