skip to main content
skip to footer
Target New Arrivals
Back to School
College
Halloween
Clothing, Shoes & Accessories
Home & Decor
Kitchen & Dining
Patio, Lawn & Garden
Grocery
Household Essentials
Baby
Beauty
Personal Care
Sports & Outdoors
Pets
Health
Wellness
School & Office Supplies
Toys & Games
Electronics & Tech
Video Games
Movies, Music & Books
Party Supplies
Gift Ideas
Gift Cards
Shop by Community
Target Optical
Deals
Clearance
New Arrivals
Back to School
College
Top Deals
Target Circle Deals
Weekly Ad
Shop Order Pickup
Shop Same Day Delivery
Registry
RedCard
Target Circle
Find Stores
Target Circle™
Target Circle™ Card
Target Circle 360™
Registry & Wish List
Weekly Ad
Find Stores
Categories
Deals
Pickup & delivery
search
birthday pencil
Target
Party Supplies
birthday pencil
Get top deals, latest trends, and more.
Email address
Sign up
Privacy policy
Terms
Filter
Sort
Deals
Type
Occasion
Pieces in Set
Color
Price
Guest Rating
Package Quantity
1,000+ results
for “birthday pencil”
Pickup
Shop in store
Same-day Delivery
Shipping
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness 10th Pink Rose Gold Birthday - Happy Birthday Party Round Candy Sticker Favors - Labels Fits Chocolate Candy (1 sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Mini Camping Party Stickers, Happy Camper Kids Birthday Round Candy Favors - Small Labels Fit Chocolate Candy (1 Sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$14.99
Big Dot of Happiness Let’s Rally - Pickleball - Birthday or Retirement Party Candy Favor Sticker Kit - 304 Pc
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Making Waves - Swim Team - Swimming or Birthday Party Round Candy Sticker Favors - Labels Fits Chocolate Candy (1 sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
4
(1)
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Light Green and Teal Wavy Birthday Wine Labels for Bottles, Retro Party Decorations, Pink Wine Bottle Label Stickers - Set of 4
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$13.99
Big Dot of Happiness Farm Animals - Barnyard Baby Shower or Birthday Party Water Bottle Sticker Labels - Set of 20
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$14.99
Big Dot of Happiness Teal Green and Yellow Wavy Birthday Buttons, 3-inch Happy Birthday Party Badge, Wearable Party Decor, Pinback Buttons - Set of 8
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Little Cutie Clementine - Orange Citrus Baby Shower or Birthday Party Round Candy Sticker Labels Fits Chocolate Candy 108 Ct
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Mini Safari Animals Party Stickers, Jungle Birthday Party or Baby Shower Round Candy Favors - Small Labels (1 Sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Rainbow Unicorn - Baby Shower or Birthday Party Round Candy Sticker Favors - Labels Fits Chocolate Candy (1 sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$24.99
Boy Shark Birthday Stickers for Kisses (3 Sheets)
Just Candy
Add to cart
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Gear Up Robots - Birthday Party or Baby Shower Round Candy Sticker Favors - Labels Fits Chocolate Candy (1 sheet of 108)
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
Sponsored
$9.99
Big Dot of Happiness Orange and Yellow Wavy Birthday Wine Labels for Bottles, Retro Party Decorations, Pink Wine Bottle Label Stickers - Set of 4
Big Dot of Happiness
Add to cart
$3.69
reg
$4.29
Sale
Ticonderoga 18ct Pencil Presharp Yellow: No. 2 Wood Cased, 1.0mm Point, Erasable, School Supplies for Kids, Ages 5+
Ticonderoga
4.9
(1446)
Loved for:
pre-sharpened convenience
Add to cart
$1.99 - $10.69
reg
$2.59 - $13.79
Sale
Sharpened #2 Wood Pencils - up&up™
up&up
4.8
(2838)
Loved for:
pre-sharpened convenience
Add to cart
$5.59
reg
$6.59
Sale
Ticonderoga 30ct Pencil Yellow
Ticonderoga
4.8
(1085)
Loved for:
pre-sharpened
Add to cart
$2.99
Ticonderoga 12ct Pencil Nonsharp Yellow
Ticonderoga
4.8
(1164)
Add to cart
$4.49
reg
$4.99
Sale
Ticonderoga 24ct Pencil Nonsharp Yellow: School Supplies, Erasable, Yellow, Kids, Art & Stationery, Ages 10+
Ticonderoga
New at
target
¬
4.7
(442)
Loved for:
pre-sharpened
Add to cart
Sponsored
of 46
Page 1
Page 18
Page 20
Trending now
Skip to next section
$2.99
was
$4.29
New lower price
Ticonderoga 4ct My First Pencil
4.8 out of 5 stars with 1026 ratings
1026 reviews
Add to cart
$3.69
reg
$4.29
Sale
Ticonderoga 18ct Pencil Presharp Yellow: No. 2 Wood Cased, 1.0mm Point, Erasable, School Supplies for Kids, Ages 5+
4.9 out of 5 stars with 1446 ratings
1446 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$1.99 - $10.69
reg
$2.59 - $13.79
Sale
Sharpened #2 Wood Pencils - up&up™
4.8 out of 5 stars with 2838 ratings
2838 reviews
Add to cart
$2.99
Ticonderoga 12ct Pencil Nonsharp Yellow
4.8 out of 5 stars with 1164 ratings
1164 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$9.89
Ticonderoga 12ct My First Pencil Presharp Neon: Jumbo Fat Primary Toddler Pencils, Non-Toxic, Latex-Free, 3.3mm
4.7 out of 5 stars with 83 ratings
83 reviews
Add to cart
$29.10
Ticonderoga® My First® Short Wooden Pencils, Large Triangle Barrel, Sharpened, #2 HB Soft, With Eraser, Primary Colors, 12 Per Pack, 2 Packs
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$5.59
reg
$6.59
Sale
Ticonderoga 30ct Pencil Yellow
4.8 out of 5 stars with 1085 ratings
1085 reviews
Add to cart
$3.99
Ticonderoga 10ct Pencil Presharp Striped: Presharpened School Supplies for Kids, Back to School Essentials
4.8 out of 5 stars with 544 ratings
544 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$2.99 - $5.99
Wood Pencil and Sharpener Kit - up&up™
4.8 out of 5 stars with 154 ratings
154 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$4.49
reg
$4.99
Sale
Ticonderoga 24ct Pencil Nonsharp Yellow: School Supplies, Erasable, Yellow, Kids, Art & Stationery, Ages 10+
4.7 out of 5 stars with 442 ratings
442 reviews
Add to cart
$2.99
Ticonderoga 12ct Pencil Black
4.8 out of 5 stars with 599 ratings
599 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$3.99
Ticonderoga 10ct Neon Pencil
4.9 out of 5 stars with 112 ratings
112 reviews
Add to cart
$13.39
reg
$15.79
Sale
72ct Ticonderoga Wood #2 Pencil Yellow
4.8 out of 5 stars with 240 ratings
240 reviews
Add to cart
$2.79
12ct #2 HB Pencils 2mm Pre-sharpened Premium American Wood Yellow - U.S.A. Gold: Wooden Stationery, Latex-Free Eraser
4.7 out of 5 stars with 349 ratings
349 reviews
Add to cart
$18.99
Ticonderoga® No. 2 Pencils, Pre-Sharpened, 12 Per Pack, 3 Packs
3.7 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
3 reviews
Add to cart
$17.81
Ticonderoga® My First® Short Wooden Pencils, Large Triangle Barrel, Sharpened, #2 HB Soft, With Eraser, Yellow, 12 Count
1 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$15.59
Ticonderoga® Wooden Pencil Pastel, Sharpened, Pack of 18
3 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
2 reviews
Add to cart
$9.99
reg
$12.99
Sale
Enday Pastel Sharpened Pencils #2, 24 Pack Colored Pencils for Kids & Adults, Pre-Sharpened Pastel Color Pencils Bulk School Supplies for Teachers
1 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$9.99 - $14.99
reg
$14.99 - $19.99
Sale
Enday Jumbo Pencils For Preschoolers No 2 for Kids, Kindergarten School Supplies, Fat Pre-Sharpened Round Pencil with Eraser Top for kids ages 4-8
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$26.33
Ticonderoga Holo-Foil Black Wood #2 Noir Pencils (12 Count, 3 Pack) - School & Office Supplies
4.4 out of 5 stars with 7 ratings
7 reviews
Add to cart
$15.19
Ticonderoga® My First® Ticonderoga® Pencil, Pack of 12
5 out of 5 stars with 53 ratings
53 reviews
Add to cart
$19.99 - $39.99
reg
$29.99 - $59.99
Sale
Pencils Bulk #2 - Pre-sharpened pencils #2 Wood-Cased Yellow Sharpened Pencils for Kids with Latex-Free Eraser Top for Office and Classroom Supplies
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$28.43
Ticonderoga® My First® Short Wooden Pencils, Large Triangle Barrel, Sharpened, #2 HB Soft, With Eraser, Yellow, 12 Per Pack, 2 Packs
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1 review
Add to cart
$16.92
Arctic Blue #2 HB Pencils, 18 Count
Add to cart
