skip to main content
skip to footer
Target New Arrivals
Back to School
College
Halloween
Clothing, Shoes & Accessories
Home & Decor
Kitchen & Dining
Patio, Lawn & Garden
Grocery
Household Essentials
Baby
Beauty
Personal Care
Sports & Outdoors
Pets
Health
Wellness
School & Office Supplies
Toys & Games
Electronics & Tech
Video Games
Movies, Music & Books
Party Supplies
Gift Ideas
Gift Cards
Shop by Community
Target Optical
Deals
Clearance
New Arrivals
Back to School
College
Top Deals
Target Circle Deals
Weekly Ad
Shop Order Pickup
Shop Same Day Delivery
Registry
RedCard
Target Circle
Find Stores
Target Circle™
Target Circle™ Card
Target Circle 360™
Registry & Wish List
Weekly Ad
Find Stores
Categories
Deals
Pickup & delivery
search
mystery plushies
Target
Toys & Games
mystery plushies
Get top deals, latest trends, and more.
Email address
Sign up
Privacy policy
Terms
Filter
Sort
Deals
Age
Brand
Character
Price
Animal
Type
Guest Rating
1,000+ results
for “mystery plushies”
Pickup
Shop in store
Same-day Delivery
Shipping
$21.99
Squishmallows 10" Sky The Graduation Squid Plush -2026 High School & College Graduation Squid w Cap Stuffed Animal-Classroom Celebration Gift for Kids
Squishmallows
4.8
(4)
Add to cart
$27.99
Squishmallows Original 12-Inch Rosie The Pig- Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Pig Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
2.5
(2)
Add to cart
$21.98
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Peter The Pig - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Pig Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boy
Squishmallows
3.3
(3)
Add to cart
$19.99
Squishmallows Original 10" Nichelle The Dinosaur- Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(1)
Add to cart
$21.99
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Magtus The Snake - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(1)
Add to cart
$23.99
Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Tails - Sonic The Hedgehog- Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible SEGA Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(5)
Add to cart
$17.99
Squishmallows 8" Ladybug Citlalli W Heart Antennae Jazwares Plush- Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal- Great Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(1)
Add to cart
$29.99
Squishmallows 8-Inch Kermit & Miss Piggy Set- The Muppets- Official Jazwares Plush- Collectible Puppet Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
4
(4)
Add to cart
$34.99
Squishmallows 8-Inch Bartie & Emmy Elves Set- Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Elf Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
3
(4)
Add to cart
$15.99
reg
$19.99
Sale
Squishmallows 10-Inch Beetlejuice- Official Jazwares 2026 Plush- Collectible Large Beetlejuice Figure, Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
Add to cart
$39.99
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Dinosaur Set - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(1)
Add to cart
$10.19
reg
$11.99
Clearance
Aphmau 6" Dragons Plush
Aphmau
4.7
(51)
Add to cart
Sponsored
$49.99
Squishmallows Mystery One 10" & Two 8" 3-Squish Value Pack - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift Set for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
Add to cart
$19.99
reg
$24.99
Sale
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Ernest The Monster- Official Jazwares Plush- Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(2)
Add to cart
$6.99
Disney Lilo & Stitch Easter Small Plush Angel: Polyester Stuffed Character Animal Toy
Disney
3
(2)
Add to cart
$24.99
Squishmallows 10-Inch Ernesto The Peppermint Latte- Official Jazwares Plush- Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy-Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(4)
Add to cart
$17.99
Squishmallows Original 8-Inch Melrose The Cassowary Plush - Collectible Bird Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(1)
Add to cart
$29.99
Squishmallows 10-Inch Ignacio The Snowman - Official Jazwares Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
1
(1)
Add to cart
$16.99
reg
$19.99
Clearance
FAO Schwarz 10" Big Tails Husky Plush
FAO Schwarz
4.7
(85)
Add to cart
$44.99
Squishmallows 12 Inch Plush | Natnat the Pastel Blue Alien
Squishmallows
Add to cart
$16.99
reg
$19.99
Clearance
Disney Signature Collection Flounder Clubhouse Plush Stuffed Animal: Fish Character, Polyester Material, 9.25" Height, 17" Depth, 0.81 lb.
Disney
4.2
(6)
Add to cart
$34.99
Squishmallows Original 10-Inch Richie The Axolotl- Official Jazwares Plush- Collectible Soft & Squishy Stuffed Animal Toy- Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
4.8
(4)
Add to cart
$19.99
Squishmallows 8" Clarice - Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer Plush - Collectible Soft & Squishy Reindeer Stuffed Animal Toy - Gift for Kids, Girls & Boys
Squishmallows
5
(2)
Add to cart
Sponsored
of 50
Page 1
Page 16
Page 18
Trending now
Skip to next section
Bestseller
$7.99
Fuggler Alley Cats Keyring Charms 5"
4.4 out of 5 stars with 40 ratings
40 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$9.99
HAPPY HAUL Disney Stitch Sleepy Stars Vinyl Plush Clip-on Surprise Toy
4.9 out of 5 stars with 35 ratings
35 reviews
Add to cart
$11.99
Aphmau 6” Mystery MeeMeow Plush Halloween
5 out of 5 stars with 5 ratings
5 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$9.99
HAPPY HAUL Disney Into the Woods Vinyl Plush Clip-on Surprise Toy
4.8 out of 5 stars with 22 ratings
22 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$9.99
Fuggler Care Bears Keyring Charms 5"
4.3 out of 5 stars with 33 ratings
33 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$7.99
Fuggler Baby Baddies Keyring Charms 5"
4.5 out of 5 stars with 54 ratings
54 reviews
Add to cart
Bestseller
$5.99
Fuggler Fugg Nuggets-S1
4.6 out of 5 stars with 64 ratings
64 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$12.99
Care Bears Surprise Reveal Caring Cuties Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 92 ratings
92 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$11.89
reg
$16.99
Sale
L.O.L. Surprise! Loves Hello Kitty and Friends Reversible Plush Surprise - Blind Plush with Matching Tot and Keychain
4.8 out of 5 stars with 125 ratings
125 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$7.99
Super Duper Plush Blind Assortment 1
3.3 out of 5 stars with 13 ratings
13 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$15.99
Monboo Monster Paradise Series Stuffed Plush Collectible Keychain Blind Box Surprise
4.7 out of 5 stars with 32 ratings
32 reviews
Add to cart
$16.99
Laura Girl Cute Pet Dessert Shop Series Plush Collectible Surprise Blind Box
4.9 out of 5 stars with 308 ratings
308 reviews
Add to cart
$19.99
Monboo Forest Town Series Plush Keychain Collectible Surprise Toy Blind Box
4.7 out of 5 stars with 33 ratings
33 reviews
Add to cart
$11.99
Pusheen Assorted Gamer Plush Surprise Box
4.6 out of 5 stars with 15 ratings
15 reviews
Add to cart
$9.99
Happy Haul Disney Scents of Style Blind Box Clip-On Plush 4.5” Scented Vinyl Head Collectible Toy Short-Run Drop Ages 8+
4.4 out of 5 stars with 37 ratings
37 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$12.99
Mr. Pa Critter Cuties Series Plush Collectible Surprise Blind Box
4.8 out of 5 stars with 111 ratings
111 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$11.99
Aphmau 6” Mystery MeeMeow Plush Series 10 Bakery
5 out of 5 stars with 25 ratings
25 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$11.99
Aphmau 6” Mystery MeeMeow Plush - MyStreet
4.3 out of 5 stars with 15 ratings
15 reviews
Add to cart
$11.99
PrestonPlayz Mini Mystery Plush Series 1
4.8 out of 5 stars with 33 ratings
33 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$11.99
Pusheen Assorted Fruit Plush Surprise Box
4.7 out of 5 stars with 21 ratings
21 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$15.99
was
$16.99
New lower price
Aphmau Vinyl Plush Bag Charm
4.4 out of 5 stars with 14 ratings
14 reviews
Add to cart
$7.99
Squishmallows 5" Care Bears Fall Theme Blind Bag Little Plush
4.3 out of 5 stars with 7 ratings
7 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$5.99
Disney Stitch Attachmeez Series 2 Collectible Mini Figures
4.8 out of 5 stars with 25 ratings
25 reviews
Add to cart
Highly rated
$11.99
Moriah Elizabeth 6" PDQ Babies Mystery Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 35 ratings
35 reviews
Add to cart
