Target New Arrivals Fourth of July Back to School College Clothing, Shoes & Accessories Home & Decor Kitchen & Dining Outdoor Living & Garden Grocery Household Essentials Baby Beauty Personal Care Sports & Outdoors Health Wellness School & Office Supplies Toys & Games Electronics Video Games Movies, Music & Books Party Supplies Gift Ideas Gift Cards Pets Ulta Beauty at Target Shop by Community Target Optical Deals Clearance New Arrivals Back to School College Top Deals Target Circle Deals Weekly Ad Shop Order Pickup Shop Same Day Delivery Registry RedCard Target Circle Find Stores

mystery toy

Popular Filters

1,000+ results for “mystery toy”

$4.99

5 Surprise A-Lot-A Axolotls Mini Figure

4.4(252)

$4.99

Disney Doorables In Full Bloom Mini Peek 15 Mystery Floral Themed Mini Figures Assemble and Display Collectible Surprise Toy Fans Tweens and Kids 5+

Disney Doorables

4.9(41)

Loved for: cute designs

$9.99

5 Surprise NBA Ballers Series 2 by ZURU: PVC Mini Figure Sports Toy

3.9(90)

$9.99

5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2: Rubber Compound Mini Figure with Accessory Pieces

4.5(412)

Loved for: adorable designs

Recommendations for you

$4.99
5 Surprise A-Lot-A Axolotls Mini Figure
4.4 out of 5 stars with 252 ratings
Highly rated
$9.99
Surprise My Mini Baby Sweethearts S1
4.6 out of 5 stars with 169 ratings
$4.99
Hatchimals Bloom Pack
4.2 out of 5 stars with 14 ratings
Highly rated
$9.99
5 Surprise My Mini Baby Series 2: Rubber Compound Mini Figure with Accessory Pieces
4.5 out of 5 stars with 412 ratings
Highly rated
$12.99
My Mini Baby Disney by ZURU
4.4 out of 5 stars with 157 ratings
$10.97
MGA's Miniverse Make It Mini Minecraft - Crafting, Mining, Pixel, Tools, Animals
3.5 out of 5 stars with 96 ratings
Highly rated
$11.99
Moriah Elizabeth 6" PDQ Babies Mystery Plush
4.7 out of 5 stars with 33 ratings
Highly rated
$7.99
Mini Brands Mini Masterpieces
4.6 out of 5 stars with 102 ratings

$10.99

Our Generation Surprise Pets Puppy Series - 1 of 6 Collectible Mystery Boxes Accessories for 18" Dolls: Fits 18-Inch Size Dolls

4.6(108)

Loved for: adorable design

$5.49

L.O.L. Surprise! Mermaids Makeover Magic Baby Sisters with Color-Change Mermaid Tails

L.O.L. Surprise!

4.7(46)

Loved for: cute design

$8.99

Littlest Pet Shop - Surprise Pet Pairs

Littlest Pet Shop

4.5(145)

Loved for: adorable figures

$3.99

Littlest Pet Shop Surprise Reveal Collectible Pet Figures

Littlest Pet Shop

4.6(72)

Loved for: adorable design

Sponsored

$11.99

L.O.L. Surprise! Loves Care Bears Tots Doll: Articulated Fashion Figure with Accessories

L.O.L. Surprise!

4.5(110)

Loved for: adorable design

$2.99

Mash'ems Marvel Spidey & His Amazing Friends Surprise Reveal Figures

4.4(226)

Loved for: Surprise Element

$3.89

was $5.49

New lower price

L.O.L. Surprise! Eye Spy Series Baby Sisters Doll: PVC Material, No Articulation, Includes Figure & Accessories

L.O.L. Surprise!

4.5(96)

$14.49

L.O.L. Surprise! Loves Strawberry Shortcake Tots with Scented Dolls, Pets, Strawberry House Playset

L.O.L. Surprise!

4.7(126)

Loved for: adorable designs

Related deals

$12.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Minecraft Movie Bee Plush Toy, Soft Block-Style Character, Collectible Stuffed Animal
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$20.00
reg $25.00 Sale
MerryMakers Trash Truck's Hank Doll
Highly rated
$16.99 - $129.99
reg $20.99 - $199.99 Sale
Miraculous Ladybug, 4-1 Surprise Miraball, Toys for Kids with Collectible Character Metal Ball, Kwami Plush, Glittery Stickers and White Ribbon
4.6 out of 5 stars with 7 ratings
$10.99 - $31.45
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
Peppa Pig MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters from TV Shows - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$10.99 - $33.99
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
My Little Pony MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters from TV Shows - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
3.7 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
$20.00
reg $25.00 Sale
MerryMakers The Couch Potato Plush
$10.99 - $33.99
reg $12.99 - $35.99 Sale
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles MiraBall, 3-in-1 Surprise, Blind Box Toys for Kids - Collectable Characters - Metal Ball, Plush, Stickers, White Ribbon
3.7 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
$19.20
reg $24.00 Sale
MerryMakers Captain Undperpants Doll
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$12.99
reg $17.99 Sale
Miraball Surprises Retro - Blind Capsule Toy with Expandable Memory Foam Plush & Stickers - Fun Mystery Plush Ball for Kids Collecting
$24.00
reg $30.00 Sale
MerryMakers Pizza and Taco Puppet Set
$19.99
reg $41.65 Sale
Joyfy 36Pcs Kids Mini Plush Animal Toy Set Easter Christmas Bulk Stuffed Keychain Party Favors Animals Decoration Toys Carnival Prizes Birthday Gift
5 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
$16.00
reg $20.00 Sale
MerryMakers The Day The Crayons Quit Green 12" Plush
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
$9.99
reg $12.99 Sale
Trolls Band Together Hairmony Mixers Branch Plush Toy with Sound
$20.00
reg $25.00 Sale
MerryMakers The Big Cheese Plush
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
$12.99
reg $17.99 Sale
Miraball Surprises SpongeBob - Blind Capsule Toy with Expandable Memory Foam Plush & Stickers - Fun Mystery Plush Ball for Kids Collecting
$22.99
reg $29.99 Sale
Miraball Maxi Surprise Box, Kitties - MEGA Plush Toy with Hidden Surprises & Playable Blind Box - 10" Soft Plush, Fun Playscape for Kids
$16.00
reg $20.00 Sale
MerryMakers The Day The Crayons Quit Red 12" Plush
$29.99
reg $39.99 Sale
Despicable Me Minions 'Mel' Character Pillow Buddy
$25.99
reg $51.09 Sale
Joyfy 4 Pcs Emotional Support Plushies, Easter Fast Food Plush Stuffed Toys Set, Cute Burger Fries & Milkshake Plush Pillow Fun Comfort Food Gift Box
$11.99
reg $14.99 Sale
Funko Plush Keychain Mystery Mini: Harry Potter (One Random Mystery Mini Figure Per Purchase)
$23.99
reg $25.99 Sale
Jujutsu Kaisen Hidden Inventory - Suguru Geto (Beach) Sitting Pose Plush 7"H
$16.00
reg $20.00 Sale
MerryMakers The Day The Crayons Quit Blue 12" Plush
$12.99
reg $16.99 Sale
Funko Five Nights at Freddys Frostbite Balloon Boy Plush
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
$20.00
reg $25.00 Sale
MerryMakers Gilbert the Goblin Plush

$9.99

Surprise My Mini Baby Sweethearts S1

4.6(169)

Loved for: cute designs

$5.99

Littlest Pet Shop Surprise Reveal Collectible Plush Pets

Littlest Pet Shop

4.6(65)

Loved for: adorable design

$4.99

Littlest Pet Shop Surprise Reveal Collectible Pet Figures Single Pack - 18pc

Littlest Pet ShopNew at

4.3(28)

$4.99

Disney Lilo & Stitch Collectible Mini Figure Blind Capsule 2” Surprise Character Toy

4.6(60)

Sponsored

$9.99

MGA's Miniverse Real Baby Classics

MGA's Miniverse

4.6(174)

$10.99

Our Generation Surprise Beauty Bags Spa Series - 1 of 6 Collectible Mystery Boxes Accessories for 18" Dolls

4.5(77)

Loved for: adorable designs

$11.99

Disney Doorables In Full Bloom Multi Peek Series 15 Mystery Floral Themed Mini Figures Assemble Display Collectible Surprise Toy Fansand Kids' 5+

Disney Doorables

4.6(36)

Loved for: adorable design

$3.99

Transformers Tiny Turbo Changers Surprise Mini Action Figures Get 1 of 15 Collectible Characters

4.1(22)

$9.99

MGA's Miniverse Make It Mini Cafe Series 5

MGA's Miniverse

4.6(91)

$8.99

L.O.L. Surprise! Eye Spy Series Pets Doll: Includes Color-Changing Features, Articulated Figure, Accessory Pieces

L.O.L. Surprise!

4.4(39)

$9.99

Littlest Pet Shop Surprise Reveal Collectible Figures - 3pk

Littlest Pet Shop

4.3(78)

Loved for: Vibrant Colors

$4.99

Hatchimals Bloom Pack

4.2(14)

Sponsored

Get top deals, latest trends, and more.