skip to main content
skip to footer
Black-owned or founded brands at Target
Christmas
Grocery
Clothing
Baby
Home
Furniture
Kitchen & Dining
Outdoor Living & Garden
Toys
Electronics
Video Games
Movies
Sports & Outdoors
Beauty
Personal Care
Health
Pets
Household Essentials
Arts
School & Office Supplies
Party Supplies
Gift Ideas
Luggage
Gift Cards
Clearance
Top Deals
Target Circle Offers
Weekly Ad
Target New Arrivals
#TargetStyle
Women's New Arrivals
Beauty New Arrivals
Kids' New Arrivals
Baby New Arrivals
Men's New Arrivals
Home New Arrivals
Target Finds
Shop Order Pickup
Same Day Delivery
Registry
RedCard
Target Circle
Find Stores
Registry
Weekly Ad
RedCard
Target Circle
Find Stores
Categories
Deals
What’s New
Pickup & Delivery
go
Sign in
cart 0 items
Paper Magic
Paper Magic (34)
How are you shopping today?
Pickup
In-store pickup, ready within 2 hours
Same Day Delivery
Scheduled contactless delivery as soon as today
Shipping
Free with RedCard or $35 orders*
*
Exclusions Apply.
Filter
Category
Type
Price
Deals
Guest Rating
FPO/APO
34 results
Paper Magic 24ct Silly Sweet Valentine's Day Scratch off Joke Classroom Exchange Cards
Paper Magic
4.9 out of 5 stars with 8 ratings
8
$4.00
When purchased online
Minecraft 16ct Giant Sticker Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
3.3 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
3
$4.00
When purchased online
Marvel Spider-Man 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Tattoo Bands - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1
$4.00
When purchased online
Disney Princess 32ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Stickers - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
4.7 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
3
$2.50
When purchased online
Star Wars: The Mandalorian 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Glow Sticks - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
3.2 out of 5 stars with 13 ratings
13
$4.00
When purchased online
Disney Frozen 12ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Friendship Bracelets - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1
$4.00
When purchased online
Jurassic World 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Glow Sticks - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
3.5 out of 5 stars with 11 ratings
11
$4.00
When purchased online
Rachael Hale 16ct Giant Sticker Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 3 ratings
3
$4.00
When purchased online
Mad Libs 24ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
4.1 out of 5 stars with 8 ratings
8
$4.00
When purchased online
Harry Potter 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Pencils - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
4.6 out of 5 stars with 5 ratings
5
$4.00
When purchased online
Paper Magic 32ct Valentine's Day Wild Life Classroom Exchange Cards with Tattoos
Paper Magic
4.8 out of 5 stars with 5 ratings
5
$2.50
When purchased online
Marvel Avengers 32ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Tattoos - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
2
$2.50
When purchased online
PAW Patrol 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Erasers - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
1.4 out of 5 stars with 14 ratings
14
$4.00
When purchased online
Paper Magic 16ct Creepy Bug Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Sticky Toys
Paper Magic
3 out of 5 stars with 7 ratings
7
$4.00
When purchased online
Star Wars 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Pencils - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 1 ratings
1
$4.00
When purchased online
Paper Magic 16ct Heart Buddy Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Sticky Toys
Paper Magic
3 out of 5 stars with 4 ratings
4
$4.00
When purchased online
Disney Mickey Mouse & Friends 16ct Giant Sticker Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
3.2 out of 5 stars with 5 ratings
5
$4.00
When purchased online
Minions 16ct Giant Sticker Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
$4.00
When purchased online
LOL Surprise 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Magnets - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 5 ratings
5
$4.00
When purchased online
Disney Lightyear 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Glow Sticks - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
1.7 out of 5 stars with 13 ratings
13
$4.00
When purchased online
DC Super Pets 32ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Tattoos - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 2 ratings
2
$2.50
When purchased online
Disney Descendants 3 16ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Tattoo Bracelets - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
$4.00
When purchased online
PJ Masks 16ct Giant Sticker Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
$4.00
When purchased online
Gabby's Dollhouse 32ct Valentine's Day Classroom Exchange Cards with Stickers - Paper Magic
Paper Magic
5 out of 5 stars with 8 ratings
8
$2.50
When purchased online
undefined of 2
Previous page
Next page
Holiday Shop
Party Supplies
Home
Toys
Get top deals, latest trends, and more.
Email address
Sign up
Privacy policy
Footer
About Us
About Target
Careers
News & Blog
Target Brands
Bullseye Shop
Target's Coronavirus Response
Sustainability & ESG
Press Center
Advertise with Us
Investors
Affiliates & Partners
Suppliers
TargetPlus
Help
Target Help
Returns
Track Orders
Recalls
Contact Us
Feedback
Accessibility
Security & Fraud
Team Member Services
Stores
Find a Store
Clinic
Pharmacy
Optical
More In-Store Services
Services
Target Circle
RedCard
Target App
Registry
Same Day Delivery
Order Pickup
Drive Up
Free 2-Day Shipping
Shipping & Delivery
More Services
Pinterest
Facebook
Instagram
Twitter
Youtube
Tiktok
Terms
CA Supply Chain
Privacy
CA Privacy Rights
Your Privacy Choices - CA
Interest Based Ads