Fireside By Dearfoams Women's New Castle Genuine Shearling Cross Band Fuzzy Slide Slipper

These New Castle Genuine Shearling Cross Band Slides are kind of a conundrum. Not my typical style, as I've never found the cross band appearance attractive. But, my sister gifted me a pair of cheap cross band slippers from another brand, and I was so surprised by how comfortable and secure they felt that when I saw the Fireside line had a version, I decided to try them. As a looooooooooooong time Fireside fan, I would choose the Dearfoams Fireside line over ugg, bearpaw, austrailia luxe, and any other shearling & suede brand. Especially because I've consistently had positive experiences. So, it's no surprise that my go-to shoes--for indoors & outdoors--are the Women’s Moc Bootie from Dearfoams' Fireside line. In which, I wear a size 8, and I own multiple pairs (Indoor pair, outdoor pair and, of course, I have back-up pairs that I've squirreled away since they're, now, discontinued.) Accordingly, I ordered these cross band slippers in an 8 as well. But, after putting them on, initially, I felt that, perhaps, a 9 would have been a better choice in these. There is a hard "lip"/raised edge that is not comfortable AT ALL on my heel. I got a stellar price on these because I purchased them Final Sale; so, I am unable to return them; and, in truth, I've never really been one for returning items like shoes, undergarments, etc. So, I simply take it as a lesson learned. Beyond the hard-rolled raised edge, these shoes have a hard sole, in general. The sole, for me, isn't an issue...as it strikes me more as a great quality, durable aspect of the slippers. When Dearfoams advertises these as indoor/outdoor shoes, it's not an understatement. Overall, I feel the quality of these cross band slippers is top notch. The shearling is full, lush & pretty in appearance. Though, I will say, not thick or soft enough on the footbed to detract from how firm/hard the sole is. Still, I think the materials are indisputably high-quality. Not to mention that these are warm & hug my foot in the best way--minus the jab in the heel, of course. For me, unfortunately, the appearance of my feet at he front of the open toe--the way my right & left sit in the slippers with only 3 toes visible at all times; like my foot is listing to the side--is the other reason I can't bring myself to like these New Castle slippers as much as I'd hoped I would. I don't know if it's a matter of my foot shape, the way the slippers are made, or a combination of the 2...but it solidifies, for me, that I would not purchase this particular style again. If you prefer an extra firm sole, and have the right foot to complement this style, I say go for them. Because these are definitely good quality shoes. They just aren't for me personally.

Luscious--like walking on & in clouds! I'm so glad I splurged on something special for myself!

Absolutely wonderful! These slippers are so comfy. My feet don’t get to hot but not cold. Would definitely recommend.

Comfortable and soft. Wear every day! Only slippers I wear.

Nice warm slippers. My only issue is the right slipper seems to be made differently from the left causing my right foot to slide further than the left.

I feel they are cheaply made and/or at a minimum the right show is defect. As long as I wear socks, I can wear them. There is not enough fuzzy material; it does not overlay the hard stitching to the sole. I didn't return them since I got them at such a discounted price, the only reason.

These are very comfortable. I've had problems with plantar fasciitis in the past and need hard soled slippers to wear around the house. These are perfect.

Great fit and look. So comfy. Bought 4 more as gifts

Cute color and love how soft they are but the foam sole doesn’t align with the plastic from the bottom so my foot feels like I’m stepping on where the plastic sole meets and they’re not comfortable! I’d say a narrow foot would work just fine but the straps would be too loose on anyone’s foot. Sad bc I’ve been waiting on a new pair of slippers and these didn’t work out. I will be returning asap

The lack of arch support and within a short period of time the fur started falling off. Couldn’t figure out where all this grey fur was coming from than realized it was the slippers

I decided to size up since I have a high arch and wide foot. They're perfectly roomy, not too big, and very comfy.

I received my slippers a week ago and absolutely love them! So comfortable and surprisingly warm.

Look cute, it are not very comfortable.

The only thing is tooo big beautiful comfy color is deep purple

Cozy and comfy! I like that it's real shearling, not synthetic.

I’ve had these for 3 months and have worn them everyday. They keep my feet warm/comfy on hardwood floors. My husband spilled something on it and threw it in the wash/dryer. Now I it’s stretched out and the fur is kind of balled up and not furry/smooth. :( I’m really tempted to buy another pair, but I’m disappointed that it didn’t last me long. I guess wash with care.

So cute and warm! Love them

I absolutely love these 💜

These slippers are pretty comfortable but after wearing them for a couple of weeks they have now stretched out, making it difficult to walk in them. They also feel a bit clunky. Wouldn’t recommend.

I really like these slippers they are super comfy and cushiony. I usually wear with socks and they fit perfect. Unsure if they’ve stretched or just not but so without socks they feel a bit loose. Still would recommend!