cinnamon taffy

Howe Traditional Nostalgic Candies, Vintage Style Old Fashioned Candy Flavors, Salt Water Taffy, 15 Oz

Pumpkin Spice Cold Foam - 13oz - Favorite Day™

Watermelon Taffy Chews by Its Delish, Individually Wrapped Sweet & Juicy Soft Candy Taffies

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Caramel Apple, 15 Oz

Gingerbread Ice Cream Sandwich - 14.56oz/4ct - Favorite Day™

Abba Zaba 2 oz Taffy Bar – Chewy Taffy with Creamy Peanut Butter Center, Available in 1, 3, 6 & 24 Pack

Laffy Taffy Ropes Variety Pack of 7 Flavors (6 of each, total of 42)

Red Strawberry Flavored Taffy Chews by It's Delish

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Banana, 15 Oz

Cotton Candy Taffy Chews by It's Delish

Holi Scoops Vanilla Snickerdoodle Cookie Dough Discos Dairy-Free Ice Cream - 7.5oz

Brinky Strawberry Sandwich Cookies - 13.97oz/12ct

Bonomo Turkish Taffy Bars 1.5 oz – Classic Chewy Candy in Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry & Banana (Single, Multi-Pack & Variety Pack)

Meiji Yan Yan Strawberry Cream Cracker Stick with Dip - 2oz

Dubble Bubble Gumballs – Variety of Flavors | 1" Classic Chewy Gumball Candy – Available in 1, 2, 3 & 5 lb Bags

Vanilla Caramel Squares Taffy Candy by It's Delish

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Watermelon, 15 Oz

Brinky Vanilla Cookies - 13.97oz/12ct

Butterscotch Caramel Taffy by It's Delish

Black Licorice Flavored Taffy Chews by It's Delish

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Strawberry & Creme, 15 Oz

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Pineapple Ginger, 15 Oz

Snackathon Salt Water Taffy Single Flavor, Key Lime, 15 Oz

Blue Blueberry Taffy Chews by It's Delish