Women’s Phyllis Penny Loafers with Memory Foam Insole – A New Day™

The shoes looked awesome but the size ran big and too loose on my foot, especially the heel so I was stepping right out of them

These are a great intro loafer if you’re trying to decide on whether or not to purchase a loafer. As for the fake coin, I just used some Rub n’ Buff (copper color) to transform the coin to my liking.

Great looking shoe! Ive been looking for a more rounded toe loafer and this was it. I have a wide foot and high instep so the 8 left plenty of room in toe box however it is snug from instep aspect but still comfortable.

I really love them. First time where at the airport all day and my feet felt great true to size.

Stylish and Comfortable

They are a little stiff and need a good breaking in but it's a nice looking shoe.

Very comfortable, great price point.

Cute but just not worth the price. Too cheap looking and very narrow. Usually like Target shoes.

I love these! I feel they’re stylish and easy to walk in. I personally like the coin design as it’s a dupe for a higher end design. Perfect for work imo! I have slightly wider feet and these still fit fine for me

I love me some Target shoes, but these were absolute trash. They look and feel like they’re made of plastic. I could maybe get over that, but the ugly plastic “coin” in the penny slot isn’t removable.

Shoe of the season!!!! These are super cute and comfortable! Get em before they are gone!

I loved it, perfect to wear this fall

I stupidly assumed you could swap out the decorative coin for a penny. It's permanent and makes the shoes look cheap. Will be returning.

In love with these! I’m an old school penny loafer wearer from the 80s and wanted another pair without the price. These are well made, structured. After a few wears haven’t creased or anything. I wish I could remove the fake coin, I feel like after a few more wears, I’ll try again. I never wrote reviews unless I’m in love with something, and these true to size shoes deserved it!

super comfy and extremely stylish

These are super cute, soft, and true to size. Why can’t the shiny fake plastic coin be removable? Does not look authentic at all, and brings down the look of the shoe. Wanted to put a real penny in there, but the plastic coin is fixed permanently. Maybe I can get used to it, or try to antique it a little. It looks super fake.

These loafers look way more expensive than they are! Really well made (def will require some breaking in, per usual) and they seem like they will hold up. Typically wear and 8 but ended up keeping the 8.5. If you have wider feet, def size up. Memory foam on the inside as well!

These loafers blew me away. The quality is amazing and they are lined inside so they do not rub your feet. They are comparable to a luxury brand loafer. Don’t hesitate to buy these before they sell out. I bought both colors!

These shoes are so comfy, true to my size. Great price. Semi reasonable delivery time. Wish they had more colors. Wore penny loafers growing up so when I saw these I had to order before they sold out. :)

Super cute and seems comfortable. Took one star off because I'm a little frustrated with the sizing. Based off reviews (via target and tiktok), everyone suggested 1/2 size down. I did try on a size 6 in store (im a true size 6 in all shoes) and found the shoes run big so I figured a half size down would work since it worked best for everyone else. Ordered a 5.5 during a sale, thinking it'd be perfect. I was wrong, I need a 5, but unfortunately, the size 5 is sold out in both colors. Such a bummer! I have NEVER had to wear a size 5 in shoes from Target before (or anywhere else), but I noticed lately that Target shoes are running really big and inconsistent! Love these loafers so much and got it on a promotion, debating whether to keep it and make it work somehow, otherwise back to the store it goes.