Dr. Scholl's Men's Harrington II Oxford Flat Brown Leather 8.5 W

Works well for very wide feet. Oxford style is great for people who find boots uncomfortable. The material/construction holds up well for the price range. Traction is decent.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Broke one ankle years ago. Have a metal plate and pins holding things together. Because of this have a terrible time finding comfortable shoes. These are some of the best I've found. Very comfortable and hold up well. Overall quality is excellent. Real leather and a thick sole which helps in colder weather. My second pair and will keep buying as long as design and manufacturing quality doesn't change.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I'm a big guy and I'm on my feet all day. Love these shoes. Very comfortable and durable.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have been wearing these shoes for almost 20 years! Great fit and comfort! I will only buy these shoes for work.

Comfort was less than desirable. There seems to be a great deal of space and not a snug fit.

I have purchased these shoes numerous times over the years. They are comfortable and are slip resistant. I work in a wet environment and have not lipped yet.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I am on my fifth pair of Harrington Oxfords. I suffer from plantar fasciitis and was told about all sorts of exercises I needed to do. I don't do any of them because of my Dr. Scholl's. I have one pair for work, and one pair for outdoors. I stand a good part of the day as a teacher, and love to go walking on my free time. My feet are never an issue for either activity.

Go to work shoe. They are comfortable but have good soles, rugged.

Most comfortable shoes ever. Please don’t ever discontinue.

Great shoes! But I think you need to upgrade the souls to last longer. I do a lot of walking.

Great shoes. My second pair. Really help my feet feel good while wearing.

I am still on my second pair. I prefer the older ones with the yellow wear bars in the soles that worked EXCELLENT even on concrete. I wish they would bring those back. I had to use insoles, but found these to be very comfortable.

i have been wearing this style for 20 yrs best shoes ever for allround comfot durability utility style can where all 4 seasons in wisc. work or dress high toe box(hamer toes arch suport flat feet i will wear this dr schoals over all others

I opted to purchase these shoes online instead of at my local shoe store. Took over a week to get the shoes. I've now worn the shoes for a week and already the sole has peeled away on the left shoe. Wasn't doing anything out of the ordinary that would prompt the issue.

fit and comfort are good, but soles separate after wearing for 1 month. BAD, BAD, BAD. Bring back the harrington 1 sole. Will never buy another pair.

I have pirchased these shoes many times over the years. I wear them all the time while teaching school, at home, and anywhere that I am working outside. Things that I like are the stitched soles, the nonmarking aspect, the real leather, and the blue inserts. I do find that the laces wear out after about a year. Also the cushioning around the ankle peels and looks terrible...this should be remedied. The leather shoe itself polishes up nice for special events. On my most recent pair, my left shoe lower sole has begun to separate from the inner sole. Maybe not enough glue?? Or just because I bend this shoe more as I squat while working?? I still thing these are the best shoes that I have had for comfort. I have previously been a shoe repairman and when my sisters bought me my first pair of Dr. Scholl's shoes, I just kept on buying more of the same as the years went by.

Why isn't there a wide variety for 7.5 ? I cannot understand it.

These shoes scuff. My last pair (similar but not Harrington II did not scuff. When putting the shoes on the tongue wants to crimp and must be pulled straight something else the last pair did not due. I am very happy with the shoes and look forward to enjoying them for a long time.

These shoes are not anything like the ones I had purchased previously. The insides feel like you are walking on stones and the heel area comes up to about mid point on my heel.

The style or leather material of this shoe has changed regarding the upper and the stitching around the sole has also changed. It now looks more like a “industrial” shoe. The previous model could pass as a “dress” shoe. However it is seems well made and should wear well.