Holy Rebellion - (Brandeis Gender, Culture, Religion, and Law) by Ronit Irshai & Tanya Zion-Waldoks (Paperback)

About the Book

"An in-depth study of Jewish religion and law in Israel from a gendered perspective. In Holy Rebellion, Ronit Irshai and Tanya Zion-Waldoks examine social change in Israel through a rigorous analysis of the shifting entanglements of religion, gender, and law in times of cultural transformation. They explore theological, halakhic, political, and sociological processes and show how they interact with one another in ways that advance women's rights, as well as how they are met with a conservative backlash in the discourses and actions of the rabbinic establishment. Irshai and Zion-Waldoks build on legal philosopher Robert Cover's 1982 paper "Nomos and Narrative," which explained how cultural narratives and legal norms are reciprocally enforced or transformed. Expanding on this notion, Irshai and Zion-Waldoks propose a "narrative ripeness test," an analytic tool that evaluates the relationship between culture and law to assess how and when change within a minority cultural community may be accelerated or hindered by state intervention. Religious feminisms are emerging around the world, not solely in Israel, and this book helps elucidate how they create enduring and radical change. Many liberal states are also confronting an illiberal backlash and question the multicultural framework's ability to serve the needs of minorities within minorities. Therefore, the theoretical framework offered by Irshai and Zion-Waldoks is applicable beyond the Israeli case, even as it offers deeper insights into an Israeli society in turmoil"--

Book Synopsis

An in-depth study of Jewish religion and law in Israel from a gendered perspective.

In Holy Rebellion, Ronit Irshai and Tanya Zion-Waldoks examine social change in Israel through a rigorous analysis of the shifting entanglements of religion, gender, and law in times of cultural transformation. They explore theological, halakhic, political, and sociological processes and show how they interact with one another in ways that advance women's rights, as well as how they are met with a conservative backlash in the discourses and actions of the rabbinic establishment. Irshai and Zion-Waldoks build on legal philosopher Robert Cover's 1982 paper "Nomos and Narrative," which explained how cultural narratives and legal norms are reciprocally enforced or transformed. Expanding on this notion, Irshai and Zion-Waldoks propose a "narrative ripeness test," an analytic tool that evaluates the relationship between culture and law to assess how and when change within a minority cultural community may be accelerated or hindered by state intervention.

Religious feminisms are emerging around the world, not solely in Israel, and this book helps elucidate how they create enduring and radical change. Many liberal states are also confronting an illiberal backlash and question the multicultural framework's ability to serve the needs of minorities within minorities. Therefore, the theoretical framework offered by Irshai and Zion-Waldoks is applicable beyond the Israeli case, even as it offers deeper insights into an Israeli society in turmoil.

Review Quotes

"Holy Rebellion is a monumental study of Religious Zionist feminism, offering a groundbreaking framework for understanding feminist change within a conservative religious context . . . [and] a powerful analytical model for studying egalitarian change across diverse contexts. . . . Essential reading for scholars of contemporary religion, especially those interested in the intersection of religion and the state."-- "Journal of the American Academy of Religion"

"Irshai and Zion-Waldoks' book is an enrichment to the field of gender studies in Israel and for those interested in the developments Judaism is going through in the modern world." -- "Women in Judaism"

"A critically important history of Judaism in Israel and essential for academic collections on Israel, Judaism, and feminism." -- "AJL Newsletter"

"This volume is a true beacon of light at a time when Israeli society faces profoundly complex questions about its identity, in both its democratic and its Jewish character." -- "Contemporary Jewry"

"A hopeful study that doesn't flinch from the real illiberal headwinds that Religious Zionist feminism faces within Israeli society. . . . A pivotal reference for the last fifty years of Religious Zionist feminism." -- "CCAR Journal"

"Holy Rebellion combines a compelling narrative with methodological rigor in this fascinating account of the impact of feminism on Israeli Orthodoxy."--Rabbi Rachel Adler, professor emerita of modern Jewish thought, Hebrew Union College - Jewish Institute of Religion

"Holy Rebellion will become a classic in the field of religious feminist literature. This highly readable volume is the most comprehensive and rigorous analysis imaginable, from private observance of niddah to public rabbinic ordination of women to the implications the backlash holds for the very future of religion in Israel."--Blu Greenberg, author of On Women and Judaism: A View from Tradition

"A must-read for anyone seeking the most comprehensive account of the development of religious feminism in Israel to date. The unique combination of theoretical and sociological analysis leads to incisive analysis of the broader cultural, legal, social, and political implications of this phenomenon. An invaluable case study of possible modes of interaction between conservativism and radical change."--Tamar Ross, author of Expanding the Palace of Torah: Orthodoxy and Feminism

About the Author

Ronit Irshai is associate professor and the head of the Gender Studies Program at Bar Ilan University, and a research fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem. Tanya Zion-Waldoks is assistant professor in the Seymour Fox School of Education at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.