Johnston & Murphy Men's Holcomb Plain Toe Waterproof Leather Dress Lace-up Shoe

I couldn’t be more impressed with my Johnston & Murphy dress shoes. From the moment I unboxed them, the craftsmanship was obvious—premium leather, elegant stitching, and a sleek silhouette that instantly elevates any outfit. What truly stands out is the comfort. These shoes required almost no break-in period. The footbed offers excellent support, and even after a full day on my feet, they still feel great. Whether I'm at the office, a formal event, or just dressing sharp for a night out, these shoes deliver on both style and practicality. I’ve received several compliments, and people are always surprised when I say they’re not custom-made—because that’s how they feel. Johnston & Murphy has nailed the balance of timeless design and modern comfort. Highly recommended for anyone who values quality and wants a shoe that looks as good as it performs.

I recently purchased a pair of waterproof Johnston & Murphy shoes for my husband, and we are both extremely impressed with the quality and style. The craftsmanship is top-notch — from the stitching to the leather finish, everything looks and feels premium. He mentioned how comfortable they were right out of the box, with no break-in period needed, which is rare for dress shoes. They’re versatile enough to wear with both professional and more casual outfits, and he’s already received several compliments. These shoes strike a great balance between timeless design and everyday wearability. I highly recommend Johnston & Murphy for anyone looking for durable, stylish footwear that doesn’t compromise on comfort.

A perfect combination of fit and comfort. Appearance holds up very well, even under everyday wear and tear over an extended period of time. 10/10.

My son loved the shoes! He said it’s very comfortable and stylish.

Excited to wear these in the winter, seem like they will work nicely in ice and snow.

Great looking and very well made shoe. It feels light and looks fantastic with all sorts of attire.

These shoes are extremely comfortable right out of the box.

Acquired these shoes and was so impressed by the comfort and sake price that I immediately ordered a identical pair to save for the future! Can't go wrong.

Extremely comfortable and excellent fit. Like all Johnston and Murphy shoes, they're made well and look fantastic.

These shoes are well crafted, very comfortable on my feet. A great value for the money. Great store. Quick service.

This shoe has a traditional look and yet has incorporated several features that make it comfortable all day. Recommended.

Shoes have a classic look and premium quality, one of my personal favorites in my collection.

Waterproof, Very versatile shoe. Can be worn for any occasion. It is a bit tight but after wearing a couple of times it feels comfortable

The shoe looks sharp and seems to be well made. After two days, it is not yet broken in and hurts my feet.

Looks great and it was so comfortable. I had a long day with my wedding and wore it for 10+ hours and it never hurt my feet at all. It’s one of the most comfortable dress shoes I have worn.

This shoes are perfect for any occasion and very confortable.

I purchased these to wear with a suit, and they can dress up jeans or anything in between. Comfortable, supportive and waterproof. It’s still early in the break-in process but so far I would recommend.

I am very happy with the shoes. The toe box is tight but comfortable and flexes. The soles feel firm and cushy. I am happy to wear them all day!

I bought these for my son and thankfully they were true to size. I loved the look and comfort too!

I like the basic black dress shoe with my suit. They seem to be comfortable.