My almost 3 yo loves this book! I didnt think that the book cover would catch her eye but it was the one she picked up out of the batch that I had ordered. And she enjoyed it the first time and wanted to read it again snd again. A week in with her reading it at everyday, she’s still interested even though the element of surprise is not there anymore. She even thinks of this book for bedtime even without seeing it. Her enjoyment til now remains the same as her first time with it. Highly recommend!