Reduced Fat Ice Cream - 16oz - Favorite Day™

Best s’mores ice cream ever. Tasted as delicious as Ben and Jerry’s and with so few calories. I’m obsessed. Started with the cold brew and love that flavor but wish it had more chocolate chips. The smores (only had one so far) had plenty of chocolate chips. It was soooo good!!!

favorite ice cream of all time!!

I didn't realize this was reduced-anything ice cream when I grabbed it (or when I began eating it). I just wanted mint-chocolate cookie ice cream and figured I would give this brand a try. I expected the typical mediocre quality ice cream, but was pleasantly surprised! First, the ice cream is white, not green. While an easy thing to manipulate, I personally find it's a sign of good quality when you don't need to color something to convince someone it is mint. This ice cream is not quite Haagen-Dasz-level quality, but probably second to it of the ones I have had. The flavour is really nice, the cookie chunks are good and well spread throughout, and it melts nicely. I only realized it was reduced-sugar when I figured it must be pretty high-calorie for how yummy how it was and checked the nutrition information. The only other indication is that when it freezes, it freezes HARD. But as mentioned, it melts nicely when you're ready to eat. Will buy again.

First time in last time trying this ice cream will save my money. Do not recommend.

Not terrible, but not great

The picture on the curtain looks great, but don’t be fooled. I was expecting chunks of chocolate and chunks of cookie dough. There was literally one (yes, one) chunk of cookie dough in this. What a letdown. Plenty of chocolate chunks but ultimately this should just be called chocolate chunk ice cream. I’ll stick with Halo Top.

I just opened my Favorite Day chocolate peanut butter ice cream and it's almost half empty. What a joke and disappointment. I won’t be buying this brand again!

This is honestly so disgusting. Never have I had to force myself to eat ice cream but I couldn’t do it with this. The bourbon flavor is too strong and made me want to gag.

I bought the Mango and the Strawberry Anglefood and there was almost NO mango or strawberry! It's basically vanilla ice cream.. :( Two different pints of the Strawberry Anglefood had the same issue.

Tastes like ice cream got freezer burn

I love this. There are a lot of bad reviews for some reason on the flavor. I think this is the best low calorie ice cream I've ever had. I've tried them all!

very yummy and healthy and protein

I got 2 pints of the cookie dough which was seemingly melted and refrozen so it was spoiled by the time I bought them. I got home and saw the ice creams were clearly spoiled so I reached out and was refused a refund for my purchase. absolutely ridiculous

Tastes really quite bad. It's hard and icy which I expected due to the low fat but it also tastes like burnt coffee grounds and is not chocolatey or peanut butter at all. The fake sugar is so clearly fake unlike for instance the (on brand) no sugar added fudge pops

This is easily the best low calorie ice cream I’ve ever had. It doesn’t even seem low calorie at all to be honest. It’s a true delight and I’m just sad I can’t find it anywhere near me. I managed to snag one while 6 hours away, but it’s nowhere near me so that’s a bummer. It is literally SO good it’s easily my favorite ice cream now. So of course it isn’t available near me LOL

this is my go to ice cream. I lost 120 pounds over the last year and a half and am focused on building muscle right now. This ice cream helps me hit my protein goal and satisfies my sweet tooth. I eat dessert every day and 9 times out of 10 it's this ice cream. It's really delicious, and i can't stress that i wasnt 270 pounds just because, I KNOW good ice cream. All of the flavors are amazing, but chocolate peanut butter is the best. I would eat any of them every day and be just as happy as i would eating a pint of ben and jerry's (but this ice cream has a third of the calories and triple the protein so i'd be happier having it)

It tasted exactly like typical cookie dough ice cream but with less calories! I love this!

Such good macros. This flavor is my favorite. Real peanut butter swirls. Make sure to freeze well though- or else it will freezer burn

I can see why they’re always sold out. Great low calorie option

ERYTHRITOL as the 2nd ingredient!!! Or any ingredient on there. Just makes it so much worse being the top 2nd!!!