S'mores Sandwich Cookies - 10.5oz - Favorite Day™

Bought these for a gift basket for a friend. She said they were amazing and it didn’t last long in her house.

I had high hopes for these cookies but they just tasted like nothing and were honestly stale.

These are sooo good! These are the type of cookies you hide from the kids. Perfect blend of flavors.

What you’re really looking for is Oreos. Just get those instead.

It’s true that these taste pretty much like a regular black/Creme sandwich cookie, not smores at all, but my son loves it. But if you want a reg sandwich cookie, skip this and buy something cheaper.

They look like they would be gross but they are the best thing ever!

The frosting taste like marshmallow imo!Gram cookie with chocolate cookie.Taste like smores to me!SOO goooood.I never write reviews.10/10

These were ok. Didn’t taste like s’mores much at all.

These were okay. I didn’t get the s’more flavor at all, they just taste like a chocolate/vanilla sandwich cookie. No different than the ones you get in the basic inexpensive mix sandwich cookie pack we all grew up with.

Very yummy. Good combination.

They do not taste like s’mores

These were ok but just left me craving real oreos

Taste better than the Oreo brand name version! The cookies are crisp - one tastes like a very sweet graham cracker and the other is just generic chocolate cookie. These don’t taste just like s’mores but you get the graham flavor and the cream filling is sort of marshmallow/ sort of cake frosting, but they’re still great. The box is cute and somehow feels fancy. These would be so perfect in a picnic-themed gift basket.

These are good I just wish there was more of a s’mores taste to them but they’re not bad at all.

These are fine cookies, but don’t taste anything like s’mores, so I was disappointed. The cookie is not very graham cracker-ish, and the filling just tastes like regular filling to me, I couldn’t taste any marshmallow.

Taste was great, but these go stale pretty quickly. Within a couple of days they had lost their crunch. Kind of disappointing because otherwise they were great.

I wouldn’t qualify these as “s’mores” flavored. Tastes like a chocolate cookie. I’ll stick to the Oreo S’mores cookies.

They honestly taste “normal” to me. They are close enough to a s’mores flavor and I’d buy these again.

Regular cookie, not S'mores at all

These cookies are absolutely fantastic and SO MUCH better than Oreos. The cookie and cream balance is perfect and the flavor is spot on.