chewable pencil toppers

e.l.f. Eyeliner Pen - 0.05 fl oz

4.2(2811)

+ 16

Loved for: vibrant colors

$3.00

New lower price

e.l.f.

3.6(3611)

$5.99

NYX Professional Makeup Long-Lasting Slim Lip Pencil - 0.03oz

NYX Professional Makeup Suede Matte Velvet Smooth Vegan Lip Liner - 0.035oz

4.5(3982)

+ 9

Loved for: affordable price

$5.99

e.l.f. Love Triangle Lip Filler Liner - 0.007oz

4.5(1663)

+ 6

Loved for: smooth application

$4.00

New lower price

e.l.f.

4.2(798)

+ 1

$2.00

e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner - 0.03oz

e.l.f.

4.7(4454)

+ 10

Loved for: creamy texture

$5.99

NYX Professional Makeup Jumbo Eye Pencil All-in-one Eyeshadow & Eyeliner Multi-stick - 0.18 oz

Ticonderoga 18ct Pencil Presharp Yellow: No. 2 Wood Cased, 1.0mm Point, Erasable, School Supplies for Kids, Ages 5+

4.2(3226)

+ 10

Loved for: creamy texture

$3.69

reg $4.29

Sale

Ticonderoga 10ct Pencil Presharp Striped: Presharpened School Supplies for Kids, Back to School Essentials

4.9(1287)

$3.99

4.8(482)

Loved for: vibrant colors

$2.29 - $4.89

Select items on sale

BIC #2 Mechanical Pencils with Xtra Sparkle

Ticonderoga 12ct Pencil Nonsharp Yellow

4.8(2104)

Loved for: vibrant colors

$2.99

Buy 1, get 1 20% off Paper Mate mechanical pencils

4.8(1095)

$11.19 - $16.99

Lower price on select items

Paper Mate Clear Point #2 Mechanical Pencils 0.7mm Multicolored

4.7(487)

Loved for: vibrant colors

Sponsored

$7.49

reg $9.89

Sale

BIC 40pk Xtra Smooth 0.7mm Mechanical Pencils: Back to School Supplies

Ticonderoga 30ct Pencil Yellow

4.8(1104)

Loved for: smooth writing experience

$5.59

reg $6.59

Sale

Buy 1, get 1 20% off Paper Mate mechanical pencils

4.8(975)

Loved for: great quality

$3.49

Paper Mate Handwriting 5pk #2 Mechanical Pencils with Eraser and Refill 1.3mm Assorted Colors: School Supplies for Kids

Ticonderoga 4ct My First Pencil

4.8(544)

Loved for: thick lead

$4.29

Ticonderoga 12ct Pencil Black

4.8(954)

Loved for: great grip support

$2.99

Paper Mate Clear Point 3pk #2 Mechanical Pencils with Eraser & Refill 0.7mm Assorted Colors: Papermate Led Pencils

4.8(544)

Loved for: pre-sharpened

$5.99

reg $6.79

Sale

Prismacolor Premier 18pk Graphite Drawing Set: Sketch & Drawing Pencils, Presharpened, Blendable, Multicolor

4.7(910)

Loved for: comfortable grip

$19.99

Prismacolor

4.8(117)

Loved for: smooth application

$4.89

reg $6.89

Sale

BIC 26pk Xtra Strong 0.9mm Mechanical Pencils: Back to School Supplies with Thick Lead

Buy 1, get 1 20% off Paper Mate mechanical pencils

4.8(676)

Loved for: strong lead

$3.99

reg $4.49

Sale

Paper Mate 2ct Clearpoint Color Block Lime and Teal Clip

4.9(121)

Loved for: smooth writing

$2.99

reg $3.39

Sale

BIC 6pk Xtra Comfort 0.7mm Mechanical Pencils: Back to School Supplies for Students & Teachers

4.7(240)

$2.29

MSRP $2.39

BIC 8pk Xtra Precision 0.5mm Mechanical Pencils: Back to School Supplies for Detail and Test Work