Graham Cracker Pie Crust - 6oz - Favorite Day™

Absolutely no recommended. We bought it for our pies and it was crumbling apart

Grabbed 2 of these today so I could try a new no bake pumpkin cheesecake recipe. Normally I buy Keebler brand at the grocery store but I didn't feel like making a separate trip and Target only had this brand. Huge mistake. There is something way off in the flavor. I think I would have had a better tasting cheesecake had I used cardboard. Not sure if I can salvage my cheesecaskes by scraping off this horrible crust and transferring them to a better one. Will definitely not buy these again. Huge disappointment!

Arrived ope and destroyed

Got with my delivery order, came cracked in half but still will work. And it’s graham cracker crust, they’re prone to breaking. Just not the one I would’ve picked at the store lol. Good for the price

I needed a ready-made pie crust in a pinch, but my location was out of the Keebler brand. As soon as I poured my pie filling it crumbled to pieces. I made it work, but the taste wasn’t very great either. Unfortunately, I won’t buy again.

I like the quality of the item

So cheap that they couldn’t complete it. I’m making a pumpkin pie and the look of it will be horrible because there is no edge at all. I’ll pick something else next time or make my own crust. If you don’t care for the edge, then this might work for you.

Tastes old or stale. Through off the entire pie. Good thing I got Keebler crusts also, and they were way better.

Couldn't use it. It was stale.

I should have read the reviews before purchasing. It never hardened. It’s like dust. So disappointed.

I know this is labeled "ready to eat", but I tossed this in the oven at 350° for 15min to give the crust a nice little toast before adding my mix of instant vanilla pudding topped with Favorite Day whipped cream and for a last minute combo it came out delicious! It tasted even better the next day after being fully chilled in the fridge! Can't wait to explore the different flavors I can try with custards. I'm not sure about everyone else's experiences, but for me it was the equivalent of the key-lime pies in yogurt form. The texture for me was just perfect, and toasting it prior may've made the difference--I'm unsure. I just know I received zero complaints on the taste! For a little over a buck, I'd say give it a try! Not to mention, I've had it for two months in the fridge before finally getting the chance to use it without issue. Stored properly of course.

It’s the worst piecrust I’ve ever had in my life. Falls apart bad flavor they don’t stick Keebler. Shove this favorite day garbage at us. Never again same with that Tin can flavored cherries in the same brand. Awful. Thanks Target for the rotten brand. Had this been Keebler and wilderness pie I would never had this problem .

The flavor was off. It tasted like stale graham crackers and something weird, and it completely took away from the flavor of the dessert. It was also very hard to cut and just broke when I cut the pie. I always buy Keebler, but they were out, so I figured I’d try this. Never again. My 5 star cheesecake was nearly ruined- but thank goodness I could eat around the crust.

There def are a lot of reviews on here that are negative but I generally say to that: Everyone's experience AND perceptions/expectations won't be met with the same thing. As for ME, I definitely liked the pie crust. I wanted to make my own cheesecake from scratch (did the filling, just not the crust) and realized the crust would take more time than I could afford at the time, so I bought this one. It didn't crumble apart for me when pouring my cheesecake batter and spreading it, not when cooking, and not even during the cutting process. Onto that, it cut perfectly fine for me, and I was able to pull a solid piece out as well. Past THAT, it tasted perfectly good to me, my bf loved it, and my granny and auntie loved the extra one I made so no issues with the taste there either. I'd recommend it. Best thing you can do is try it for yourself!

This crust ruins the pie. It ruins the whole experience of eating pie bc it’s so hard to cut through with a fork. Keebler brand is much better

The taste is great but it will CRUMBLE. If you’re making a no bake dessert to serve to guests this is a no-go. If you’re making a little dessert for the kids it’s fine. I made a no bake dessert so I would assume if you’re baking a dessert that has moisture then it maybe less likely to crumble.

Once again, they failed to disclose "bioengineered food ingredient"! Thanks for making Thanksgiving just a little less sweet.

A good decent crust.

I normally buy Keebler graham cracker crust but the store only had their brand. I order on line and used Drive pick up to retrieve the items. Unfortunately one crust was severely crumbled and the other wasn’t fully intact as well. Taste wise it was fine but pretty disappointed in the appearance. Since I had to make pies that day, o didn’t have time to purchase replacements.

I had to write a review because of all the hate lol. I’m pretty picky and always buy the name brand tried and true crust but finally my decided to get this one as my Target no longer carries the other and I didn’t want my helper to make multiple stops. After carefully selecting an unbroken crust I baked a crumble top pumpkin pie with no issues. Can’t tell the difference. My only critique is the packaging says made with genetically modified ingredients but maybe the brand name one does too. If I would’ve known this prior to purchasing I would not have.