Ben & Jerry's Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream - 16oz

If you’re a peanut butter fanatic like me, Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Cup is the pint that dreams are made of. This flavor has been a staple in their lineup for years, and it’s easy to see why—it’s a perfect storm of creamy peanut butter ice cream swirled with thick ribbons of peanut butter and loaded with chunks of actual peanut butter cups. It’s not just ice cream; it’s an indulgent experience that hits all the right notes for anyone craving that classic Reese’s-inspired combo, but elevated to gourmet levels. Let’s break it down: The base is a rich, velvety peanut butter ice cream that’s neither too sweet nor overpowering—it’s got that nutty depth that makes you want to savor every spoonful. Then come the mix-ins: generous swirls of even more peanut butter (think gooey, melt-in-your-mouth goodness) and bite-sized peanut butter cups that add a satisfying crunch and chocolatey contrast. The texture is spot-on—chunky enough to keep things exciting without being overwhelming, and it scoops beautifully straight from the freezer. One pint (473ml) packs about 1,200 calories, so it’s definitely a treat-best-shared kind of deal, but hey, no judgments here. What sets it apart from grocery store knockoffs? Ben & Jerry’s commitment to quality shines through. They use fair-trade ingredients, cage-free eggs, and non-GMO sourcing, which adds a feel-good factor without skimping on flavor. It’s indulgent but responsible—environmentally conscious folks will appreciate the brand’s ethos. Pair it with a warm brownie for ultimate decadence, or eat it solo on a cozy night in. On a scale of 1-10, I’d give this a solid 9.5. It loses half a point only because it can be a bit messy (those swirls get everywhere!), but that’s part of the fun. If you love peanut butter and chocolate, grab a pint—you won’t regret it. Ben & Jerry’s nailed it again! 🥜🍦

Best of the best in icecream nothing better then ben & jerry @home icecream and this one is my all time favorite sweet icecream with chocolate filled with creamy peanutbutter best combo ever

This is my second favourite flavour after Cherry Garcia. It’s such a rich peanut flavour! I always end up excavating the peanut butter cups like an archaeologist lol. I’m such a big kid. It’s not the cheapest ice cream brand but it’s definitely one of the best.

One of my favorite B & J flavors! Taste like heaven on your tongue! The best kind of ice cream, especially if you grab a pint for yourself! Definitely worth the price!

I’ve always loved both peanut butter and ice cream, but this is honestly the perfect combination — it’s like having the best of both worlds in one bite! The creamy texture, the rich peanut butter flavor, and the smooth sweetness of the ice cream blend together so perfectly.

As all Ben and Jerry's, that flavour is so yummy. The packaging is always eye-catching. Although you should eat the recommended serving, it's hard not to eat the tub in one go! The texture just melts in your mouth, and on the packing, there is clear instructions of the ingredients. I highly reccomedning trying this flavour!!

This is one of my favourites Icre creams. I love the butter cups which is not to sweet. The taste is peanuty and my family enjoys it alot. It can be eaten on its own or as a sundae with your chosen toppings. This is worth paying the price for.

Rich, creamy, and packed with peanut butter cups — a decadent treat for PB lovers! The texture is smooth and indulgent, and the flavor is bold, but it can be a bit too sweet for some tastes. Still, a must-try for dessert fans!

If you’re a peanut butter lover, Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Cup is basically a dream in a pint. This flavor starts with a rich, creamy peanut butter ice cream base that’s already decadent on its own—but where it really shines is in the massive chunks of chocolate-coated peanut butter cups mixed throughout.

Lord knows Ben and Jerry’s ice cream is my favourite! The texture of the ice creams always makes my mouth happy. Packaging is always fun. Flavours are sent from the gods and they are so ethical, I applaud them. Affordable and delicious to indulge at home. Love!

This stuff is dangerously good. Creamy peanut butter ice cream packed with huge chunks of real peanut butter cups—what more could you want? It’s rich, indulgent, and totally addictive. If you’re into peanut butter, this pint won’t last long in your freezer.

The best ice cream ever. It's kinda more sweeter then other ice creams, but it sure hits the spot for a sweet tooth. The serving size is pretty fair as well. Have bought this ice cream for a few years now

If you're a peanut butter fanatic, Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Cup ice cream isn’t just a treat — it’s a full-blown celebration of everything rich, salty, sweet, and indulgent. Packaging & First Look: As always, Ben & Jerry’s keeps it fun and colorful. The iconic pint-sized tub with playful fonts and a clear description sets the tone. “Peanut Butter Ice Cream with Peanut Butter Cups” doesn’t hide behind vague marketing — it tells you exactly what you're diving into. And from the first spoonful, it delivers. Flavor Profile: The base is a rich, creamy peanut butter ice cream — smooth, dense, and deeply flavorful. It’s not just vaguely nutty — it tastes like real peanut butter churned into a silky custard. No artificial notes, no watered-down flavor. It’s indulgent from the first bite. But the real star here? The peanut butter cups. They’re scattered generously throughout the pint, not just one or two per serving. These are thick chunks of chocolate-coated peanut butter candy that pack a bold punch — slightly salty, creamy on the inside, and with that satisfying chocolate snap. The contrast between the softer ice cream and the firmer candy pieces creates a perfect bite, again and again. Texture & Mix-Ins: Ben & Jerry’s is known for its commitment to chunky, texture-rich pints, and this one doesn’t disappoint. The peanut butter cups are solid, substantial, and vary in size — from bite-sized bits to whole mini cups hidden like treasure. Every spoonful is different, which keeps the experience exciting throughout the pint. The ice cream itself is luxuriously thick and creamy. It doesn’t melt too fast, but it’s not so dense that it’s hard to scoop. It holds up well without feeling gummy or overly fatty. Sweetness & Balance: This is a very rich ice cream, so expect an intensely peanut buttery experience. It leans more sweet than salty, though there is a savory undertone that helps keep things balanced. If you’re not into bold peanut butter flavor, this might be overwhelming — but if you love Reese’s, or that salty-sweet combo, this pint is basically your soulmate. Nutritional Value (or lack thereof): Let’s be honest — this is a dessert. It’s not pretending to be light, low-cal, or guilt-free. One serving (1/3 of a pint) clocks in at around 400 calories, and let’s face it, most people won’t stop at one-third. But that’s part of the Ben & Jerry’s charm: it’s unapologetically indulgent. No corners cut. Just full-flavored, high-quality ingredients. Final Thoughts: Ben & Jerry’s Peanut Butter Cup is a rich, no-holds-barred dessert for serious peanut butter lovers. The blend of creamy texture, bold peanut flavor, and generous candy mix-ins makes this one of the best PB-centric ice creams on the market.

If you love ice cream and you love peanut butter cups then this is the ice cream to buy! Smooth peanut butter ice cream with pieces of peanut butter cups mixed in. The hint of salt really makes this product!

Lit my fave flavour of Ben and jerrys ice cream. There’s a generous amount of peanut butter cups, the ice cream is so sweet and creamy, the texture is delightful, it’s just perfect

This is such a AMAZING ice cream. I love peanut butter and ice cream. I like the lactose free. Taste just the same. Highly recommend. It is a little pricey but if you want good stuff this is for you. Texture is smooth and lots of peanut butter.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I just bought it cause it have a discount at the supermarket and I’m really happy I did it ❤️🤤

Sooooo yummy. The texture is perfect and it actually has a decent amount of PB cups in it. It also lasts a surprisingly long time in the freezer without getting freezer burn! Maybe because the ingredients are better than the other ice cream I buy, who knows. But I love this stuff ❤️

This is one of my favorite ice creams. It is made of the freshest ingredients with the best flavor! It comes in the perfect size enough for a few people to enjoy.

This is by far my favorite flavor of Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream! The serving size is huge enough for 3 or 4 times usage. The texture is smooth ice cream with frozen peanut butter cups. It tastes like you are eating a Reeces!