Protein Pints Cookies and Cream High Protein Ice Cream - 16fl oz

Very gritty & a bit bland.

This was so icy and artificial tasting. Definitely would not recommend. Don’t waste your money. Plenty of other protein options on the market that taste much better.

Incredible option for low sugar and clean ingredients

Being gluten free, it is so rare to find a GF cookies and cream ice cream. The taste is amazing and to me taste identical to regular cookies and cream flavored ice cream. I highly recommend

This is near perfect for actual healthy ice cream. Very few ingredients and doesn't have that artificial taste. It's not overly sweet or anything. We just need to see the price come down to under $4 a pint for it to really make sense to buy often.

Delicious!

I love their other flavors but this one is NOT it. Tastes fake. Not worth it.

let me start by saying, im already not a big fan of cookies and cream ice cream, but I thought id try a new flavor of protein pint. I've had the chocolate, coffee and strawberry - ranked in order of favorite. this cookies and cream wasn't bad, I mean, I won't buy it again, but if you're looking for the original like taste, stick to the three flavors I just mentioned. I've never had the cookie dough, mint chip and peanut butter flavor. after trying this flavor, not sure if I want to pay $6.99/to try the others. im not a fan of peanut butter in ice cream or shakes and mint chip doesn't do anything for me. cookie dough ice cream was my favorite growing up, but when I checked the sugars on these other flavors, the sugar was significantly greater than my favorites: chocolate, coffee and strawberry. overall, the quality of ice cream was good. I just didn't enjoy this flavor. I didn't really taste the cookie pieces and the cream didnt distinctly stand out.

This is an incredibly tasty healthier ice cream option!!!

Ummmm why you still sitting there ?! Go get this ice cream lol sooooo good! It’s not as sweet as regular ice cream that’s really the only difference which I prefer better! It’s creamy no protein taste It’s pricey but hey so are Nikes it’s worth it yolo!

Delish

This ice cream isn’t terrible, but it’s definitely not great. It has an artificial taste and a pretty bad after taste. Will not purchase again

I love literally every other flavor BUT this one. There’s a bad aftertaste and the Oreo cookies inside taste so off. Normally the Oreos are the best part but this icecream would probably taste better without them. Try a different flavor!

As someone who’s celiac and trying to get more protein in and loves a good sweet treat this is 10/10. Doesn’t taste like protein powder just taste like normal ice cream.

Taste Amazing!

Actually great. Tastes like regular ice cream. No weird after taste or mouthfeel. I’d say it is like oreo mcflurry but more like ice cream

Delicious!

One of the best cookies and cream ice creams in the aisle hands down and it takes the number 1 spot because nothing else is sub 500 calories 5 grams of sugar and 30 grams of protein I had a problem where I couldn’t stop eating ice cream and I would without hesitation inhale a Ben and Jerry’s pint of ice cream in 15 minutes over a thousand calories and I don’t even want to think of the sugar but with protein pints I indulge with passion

I initally tried the mint and it was DELICIOUS! So this Cookies&Cream was my next one up... but I was sorely mistaken. Absolutely disgusting. The texture - awful. The taste - awful. Do not recommend in the slightest.

Not a fan. The flavor was chalky and on top of that it gave me the runs pretty bad. Don’t eat if you have a sensitive tummy.