Anthropomorphism in Islam - (Edinburgh Studies in Classical Islamic History and Culture) by Livnat Holtzman (Paperback)

About the Book

Through a close, contextualized, and interdisciplinary reading in Hadith compilations, theological treatises, and historical sources, this book offers an evaluation and understanding of the traditionalistic endeavours to define anthropomorphism in the most crucial and indeed most formative period of Islamic thought.

Book Synopsis

More than any other issue in Islamic theology, anthropomorphism (tashbih) stood at the heart of many theological debates, and was mostly discussed within the circles of traditionalist Islam. The way a scholar interpreted the anthropomorphic descriptions of God in the Qur'an or the Hadith (for instance, God's hand, God's laughter or God's sitting on the heavenly throne) often reflected his political and social stature, as well as his theological affinity. This book presents an in-depth literary analysis of the textual and non-textual elements of aḥadith al-ṣifat - the traditions that depict God and His attributes in an anthropomorphic language. It goes on to discuss the inner controversies in the prominent traditionalistic learning centres of the Islamic world regarding the way to understand and interpret these anthropomorphic traditions. Through a close, contextualized, and interdisciplinary reading in Hadith compilations, theological treatises, and historical sources, this book offers an evaluation and understanding of the traditionalistic endeavours to define anthropomorphism in the most crucial and indeed most formative period of Islamic thought.

From the Back Cover

'An informative and engaging study of the Islamic tradition's attempts to grapple with conceptions of anthropomorphism across a range of historical settings. It represents a formidable survey of a complex topic that has for centuries defined classical Islamic theological discourses.' Mustafa Shah, University of London Explores the problem of anthropomorphism - a major bone of contention in eighth- to fourteenth-century Islamic theology More than any other issue in Islamic theology, anthropomorphism (tashbīh) stood at the heart of many theological debates, and was mostly discussed within the circles of traditionalist Islam. The way a scholar interpreted the anthropomorphic descriptions of God in the Qur'an or the Hadith (for instance, God's hand, God's laughter or God's sitting on the heavenly throne) often reflected his political and social stature, as well as his theological affinity. This book presents an in-depth literary analysis of the textual and non-textual elements of aḥādīth al-ṣifāt - the traditions that depict God and His attributes in an anthropomorphic language. It goes on to discuss the inner controversies in the prominent traditionalistic learning centres of the Islamic world regarding the way to understand and interpret these anthropomorphic traditions. Through a close, contextualised and interdisciplinary reading in Hadith compilations, theological treatises and historical sources, the author offers an evaluation and understanding of the traditionalistic endeavours to define anthropomorphism in the most crucial and indeed most formative period of Islamic thought. Key Features - Includes case studies of anthropomorphic traditions, tribal heritage and lore, the Hashwiyya and the traditionalists - Explores non-textual elements in the anthropomorphic traditions (including body-gestures and mimicry) - Studies rhetorical devices and rationalised argumentations in the writings of traditionalist theologians - Provides the first in-depth literary and linguistic analysis of the anthropomorphic material in the Hadith Livnat Holtzman is Chair of the Department of Arabic at Bar-Ilan University, Israel. She has published extensively on Islamic traditionalism, and is co-editor (with Caterina Bori) of A Scholar in the Shadow: Essays in the Legal and Theological Thought of Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya (2010). Cover image: (c) iStockphoto.com Cover design: [EUP logo] edinburghuniversitypress.com ISBN 978-0-7486-8956-9 Barcode

Review Quotes

[...] Livnat Holtzman has given us a dense and rich book behind which lays an impressive amount of work. [...] the book sets in motion a variety of approaches that open up different possibilities about how to read and make sense of these traditions. On the whole, it is no small thing.--Caterina Bori, Università di Bologna "Intellectual History of the Islamicate World 9 (2021)"

[A] pioneering literary and theoretical study of anthropomorphic hadith [...] Holtzman's work convincingly captures a distinct marker of Hanbali theology that greatly helps us to grasp what sets it apart from the rest of Sunni theology.--Racha El Omari, UC Santa Barbara "Journal of the American Oriental Society 141.2 (2021)"

An informative and engaging study of the Islamic tradition's attempts to grapple with conceptions of anthropomorphism across a range of historical settings... it represents a formidable survey of a complex topic that has for centuries defined classical Islamic theological discourses.-- "Mustafa Shah, University of London"

Livnat Holtzman takes a comprehensive and innovative view on aḥādīth al-ṣifāt during the formative and classical age of Sunnī Islam [...] The primary goal of Holtzman's book is to reveal the theological debates behind aḥādīth al-ṣifāt, which she pursues with impressive clarity and persuasiveness.--Pavel Pavlovitch, Sofia University St. Kliment Ohridski "Ilahiyat"

About the Author

Livnat Holtzman is an expert in Islamic theology. She specializes in traditionalist theology from the inception of Islam until the 15th century, and has published extensively on the thought of Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyya. Currently she is Senior Lecturer in the Department of Arabic at Bar-Ilan University, Israel.