MAC Magic Extension Mascara - Ulta Beauty

Bought this after many recommendations. It does make my lashes seem fuller but it clumps, flakes, and worst of all to my mind is the overpowering sweet scent of this product. It's VERY off putting. Will not rebuy.

Love it. Continuous user

Okay SO… (for reference I have oily eyelids ) I've gone through TWO tubes of this mascara and here's what I'll say, this mascara OUT-PERFORMS some WATERPROOF mascaras I have tried. This mascara does last all day for me (in a semi humid climate), I can shed a few tears and this mascara stays in place (granted if you bawl your eyes out it will flake but it does NOT run, streak, or smudge SLAAAAAAYYYYY) Anyway, here is what I ABSOLUTELY CANNOT STAND about this mascara… the wand SUCKS really bad, the bristles on the brush almost seem too short (?) for the formula, so the formula really clumps and packs onto the wand making it nearly impossible to get a clean, clump-free application, granted you do have lots of time to mess around with this mascara before it dries so that's good. BUT BESTIES!!!! HERE IS MY SOLUTION!!!! I bought the travel size of this mascara and the wand is the same but different (idk but trust me on this) I get a totally different application with the travel size wand, but it's different in the best way possible. This mascara is literal perfection when you use the travel size. Is the travel size cost effective? No. But does it make your lashes long, lushes, full of volume, and make it look like you have falsies on??? ABSOLUTELY YES. Just trust me and buy the travel size!! < 3

I love it better than the other mascara. Still stacks amazing.

DRY AND CLUMPY

Doesn't clump, outstanding volume

I love it

This mascara is the worst I've ever used! Flaky and clumpy! I wear contact lenses. It has literally ruined multiple ones and gave me a corneal laceration due to this mascara! I will never use it again and suggest if you wear contacts to stay away!

The item was recommended by a friend, whom I thought was wearing false lashes at the time. Was pleasantly surprised to find that it was this brand of mascara that gave her lashes volume and extension.

Love! Adds serious length. It has fibers that will make your lashes look longer. Bigger tube lasts roughly 3 to 4 months, like most mascaras, before you need to buy a fresh tube. I use an eyelash primer first and then an eyelash comb after applying this. Perfection.

This is one of my favorite mascaras ! I have tried SO many different ones. !! LOVE THIS ONE!

Overall I really Love this mascara!!! It does lengthen very well and makes my eyes pop!!! The only downside for me is the brush! I like the silicone brush from the stacked and the brush from the extended play!! The pigmentation is on point and I really like!! I actually used the Mac primer first, one coat of the magic extension and one coat of extended play and it worked out much better! Just some advice I will definitely use a lash comb to better separate my lashes before and after each coat. Overall I will purchase again

I love this mascara, adds extreme length and volume, does not smudge and stays all day!

I loooove this mascara!!!! I especially love that's it hoes on smooth and doesn't get clumpy like others. It's my fave and the only one I'll buy!!!!

I got this mascara because i have heard really good and amazing things. And my first time using it. My lashes clumped together plus they are not longer than normal. Just thicker. And for the price im really bummed out with the outcome.

The mascara has a chemical-like smell similar to ammonia. I had purchased two sets of this mascara for myself and as a gift but I couldn't gift someone something with such a foul odor so I tried to use it hoping it would dissipate over time. The severity of the smell did become less over time but after a few weeks of use, the product dried up and was unusable.

Waste of $$. Tube dried out one week after opening. Super clumpy. The brush is coated with a giant clump after 2 weeks to the point I cant see the bristles. Not worth the price at all.

I love this product. Not many mascara that I have tried has worked this well. I don't have much to work with when it comes to my lashes but this really brought what I have out and made them pop. Also the fact that they use great ingredients to make the product is also a plus!

I tried this mascara because if anything, im gonna have my lashes done, so im willing to try new products. this mascara lengthens and thickens the lash while making them dark enough to see 10 feet away! Ive always gotten compliments on my eye area and for my waxer to gush over *this* mascara confirmed my own rating. it does flake a bit (hence 4 stars) but doesnt smear and holds well when my eyes water while melts off seamlessly with micellar water. I like to cocktail mascaras for length/volume and Magic Extension lets me do that with one product! (but girls pleeeease always use a primer- no matter the mascara type/brand) ;)

I love this mascara!! I have always loved to trial different brands, but BENEFIT has always been my favorite! After trialing this mascara , I have a new favorite!! It made my lashes twice as long with just one coat!