Decent starter boot, not for wide feet.
Strong points: grippy & durable soles, solid waterproofing, leather quality & appearance. Weak points: stitching, narrow toe box, awkward tongue. I bought a pair of these for conservation and trail work and they've seen extremely heavy use for a year now (rain, mud, rocks, 12 mi/day, 10+ hr/day). I've given them a good bit of love (cleaning & conditioning w/saddle soap & neatsfoot oil, waxing, re-stitching) and they've lasted longer than many of my coworkers', but they're coming apart in multiple places and I've realized they don't actually fit my feet properly, so I'm ready to retire them. Here are my observations! Stitching: the stitching on one heel panel was the first thing to fail, pulling apart after about six months: I've had to repair it twice since then. Some of the stitching around the outer side of the heel and balls of the feet started coming loose after ten. I repaired the former and haven't had further issues with it yet, but I can't fix the latter and it'll eventually be a critical issue if I keep wearing these. Leather: very durable and handsome, still cleans up quite nicely. These boots have been beaten with far more than their fair share of rocks but aren't even close to wearing through anywhere. Soles: great soles, very grippy if a tad flat for my liking. I've seen countless soles come off in my line of work (some of my own included), but these are still securely attached. Laces: I replaced the laces at around seven months as they were getting concerningly worn. They're a tad slippery, but no more than average for round laces. The hooks and eyelets have proved sturdy. Waterproofing: the waterproofing was admirable while it lasted, holding up against two weeks of work largely in ankle-deep puddles and clay slop. Leaking started around six months (failure wasn't due to the undone heel- the waterproofing on that boot actually lasted slightly longer), but I waxed them and haven't noticed any leakage since. Steel toe: does the job (I need to stop getting steel toes or I'm going to get in the habit of resting massive rocks on them!), but I found the toe box cramped, and due to the steel there isn't any stretch as you're breaking in the boots. This is probably just be a me problem, as it turns out I actually need 2XWs, but I regularly got raw patches on the sides and tops of my toes and felt like my feet were being deformed. I was a tad worried about the steel making these boots awkwardly heavy, but the weight honestly hasn't been an issue, though it's still a pleasant surprise switching to a pair of lighter shoes every now and then! Comfort: as mentioned in other reviews, the tongues fit awkwardly against the shins and need careful adjustment during breaking in, but they ended up sitting okay for me and didn't cause any issues in the long run. There is some rub just above the heel: during late summer when my feet were sweating like nobody's business in the hundred-and-something degrees F my Achilles tendons looked like raw bacon, but this wasn't an issue when things were dry. My main comfort complaint is the toe box, but I've already gone over that. Overall, they're a good budget boot. I've gotten very fond of mine, but I wouldn't buy another pair as I need something wider and sturdier for the long haul.