A Secret in Tuscany - by Alan Hlad (Paperback)
$15.00Save $3.95 (21% off)
In Stock
Eligible for registries and wish lists
About this item
Additional product information and recommendations
3.0 out of 5 stars with 1 reviews
3 out of 5 stars
2 November, 2025
It was "fine"
A Secret in Tuscany by Alan Hlad Italy, 1943: With war tearing through Europe, not even the remote Tuscan hills are safe. Gianna Conti’s family has been hiding Jewish refugees on their vineyard in Chianti, but after her brother is killed by German soldiers, she joins the Italian Resistance to fight back. Decades later, in 2003, we meet an older Gianna revisiting those memories - and the weight of what was lost. This story alternates between the two timelines, blending wartime danger with reflection and grief. Normally, this setup is right up my alley - I love WWII historical fiction, and I was excited after enjoying Alan Hlda's other book, The Long Flight Home. Unfortunately, this one landed squarely in my “it was fine” category. The setting was wonderful - I don’t think I’ve ever read a WWII story centered in Italy before, and that perspective felt fresh. The descriptions of the vineyards, the hills, and the quiet courage of the resistance fighters were beautiful. But the repetition in the writing started to distract me. Every time Gianna rode her bike, her muscles burned. Every time Beppe walked, he hobbled. Every time someone frowned or smiled, the “lines on their face” deepened or softened. By the halfway point, I found myself bracing for the next recycled phrase instead of sinking into the story. The ending was sweet, and while it wrapped things up nicely, it also felt expected - the kind of resolution you could spot chapters ahead. I kept hoping for a twist or a gut punch that never came. Overall, A Secret in Tuscany is a pleasant read - the kind of book that’s good if you’re in the mood for a gentle WWII story rather than one packed with intensity or emotional depth. Not terrible, just not one I’d rush to recommend either.