Tastykake Buttercreme Iced Cupcakes - 14.25oz/12pk
$3.99 ($0.28/ounce)
In Stock
Eligible for registries and wish lists
About this item
Additional product information and recommendations
Related Categories
Discover more options
Trending Snack Cakes
$6.99($0.87/ounce)
reg $9.99 Sale
4 out of 5 stars with 21 ratings
$6.99($0.87/ounce)
reg $9.99 Sale
3.8 out of 5 stars with 26 ratings
4.0 out of 5 stars with 57 reviews
quality: 1 out of 5
taste: 1 out of 5
0% would recommend
2 recommendations
3 out of 5 stars
16 September, 2025
originally posted on tastykake
Questionable
I bought a box today and for some reason they taste fruity. Not sure why they would possibly taste like this. Anyone have any ideas?
1 reply from Tastykake team - 7 months ago
we’re sorry about your recent experience with our product. We take quality seriously and would like to learn more. Please fill out this form https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2, so one of the members of our internal team can reach out to you directly. We want to make this right.
2 out of 5 stars
10 March, 2025
originally posted on tastykake
Awful
These were a big disappointment. There was so much oil .how can it be a cupcake if it's oily? They have little to know flavor..felt like I was eating something fake.. straight in the trash
1 reply from Tastykake team - 1 year ago
we’re sorry about your recent experience with our product. We take quality seriously and would like to learn more. Please fill out this form https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2, so one of the members of our internal team can reach out to you directly. We want to make this right.
3 out of 5 stars
25 January, 2025
originally posted on tastykake
Alright
Cupcakes taste good besides the fact that the product did not come as it should’ve.
1 reply from Tastykake team - 1 year ago
we’re sorry about your recent experience with our product. We take quality seriously and would like to learn more. Please fill out this form https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2, so one of the members of our internal team can reach out to you directly. We want to make this right.
5 out of 5 stars
19 September, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
Best I've tasted since the 70's
Iam a diabetic type 2-- I treat myself every now and then, these are perfect and doesn't raise my blood sugar. The last time I ate a cupcake this soft, delicious and moist was in the 70's. Thank you so much for all the effort you do for your customers.
2 out of 5 stars
27 April, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
they used to be great, now quality is meh.
ive been buying these for since forever. since the company changed hands, they have gotten smaller, and it looks like a drunken baboon ices these. never uniform and straight with the line, if there is a chocolate stripe at all, or half way, but comeon , this is a Philadelphia Staple. get yourselves together
1 reply from Tastykake team - 2 years ago
we’re sorry about your recent experience with our product. We take quality seriously and would like to learn more. Please fill out this form https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2, so one of the members of our internal team can reach out to you directly. We want to make this right.
4 out of 5 stars
9 March, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
Love these Cupcakes (Got a special Box)
I have been eating these cupcakes since I was a little kid.. Im 35 years old now!! They are absolutely delicious and addicting lol...I just recently got a box and all the cupcakes have no cream filling. I knew something was off after the first bite. I'm sure tastykake will make it right!! They are a great company and have been around a long time for a reason!
5 out of 5 stars
7 March, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
frosting like homemade
best of any store bought national brand
1 out of 5 stars
3 March, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
Taste ok, but missing the filling
I recently bought a package to try for the first time and the cupcakes had no zero. No, not a small amount, absolutely nothing. I thought it was an accident in one but the second package had the exact same problem.
1 reply from Tastykake team - 2 years ago
we’re sorry about your recent experience with our product. We take quality seriously and would like to learn more. Please fill out this form https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2, so one of the members of our internal team can reach out to you directly. We want to make this right.
2 out of 5 stars
6 January, 2024
originally posted on tastykake
What happened to the taste?
The cupcakes do not taste the same anymore. I wish you would go back to the old recipe.
1 reply from Tastykake Brand Team team - 2 years ago
Thank you so much for reaching out. We love what we do and are committed to staying as close to those very first Tastykake treats in taste, quality, and spirit as we can! We appreciate you sharing your opinion with us.
5 out of 5 stars
27 December, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
New here
I started eating these about a week ago, and I absolutely love them. I've never heard of the brand before, and seems like the older reviews are complaining of a recipe change. However, I'm not familiar with how they tasted 'before', I am so addicted to these I left my house last night at 9pm to go to the store and buy more. They are amazing! Hey Tastykakes if you see this I wouldn't mind a coupon haha!
3 out of 5 stars
21 October, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
Love tastycake!
I buy 1-2 boxes of buttercreme cupcakes every week. Has Tastycake changed the recipe for the cake portion? Consistency and taste was very strange. I ate the first and was so concerned, I threw out the 2nd cake - thinking something is not right.
1 out of 5 stars
17 October, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
What happened
I usually love these, but there is no, I repeat, NO cream filling!
1 reply from Tastykake Brand Team team - 2 years ago
Thanks for reaching out. We are sorry to hear about your experience. Please fill out this form: https://www.tastykake.com/new-index-2 so we can speak with you directly about this and see if we can make this right.
1 out of 5 stars
3 September, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
You’re not fooling us, Flowers Foods
These used to be the best commercially- produced cupcakes around. They’re not anymore. They’re so small, less icing, way less filling, flavor and texture is not good and definitely not the same! I’d rather pay more for the old quality product rather than see a company ruin a once-favorite snack. This is not your childhood Tastycake! (The Butterscotch Krimpets suck now too!) BUMMER! 👎👎👎
2 out of 5 stars
17 June, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
The icing recipe has changed for the worst
I am a retired Baker and love buttercream icing and if made literally thousands of pounds of it and I've enjoyed these cupcakes quite honestly my whole life and they've recently changed the icing recipe and have unlimited butter and the taste is no longer the same and it's just too sweet may as well just be regular icing with the new look and Design they cut cost on the ingredients and obviously the product itself is smaller and I do have to admit Hostess as an awesome chocolate cupcake
1 out of 5 stars
19 May, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
UTTER GARBAGE
I'm old enough to remember what REAL Tastycakes used to taste like-back when WHOLESOME ingredients were used, and Tasty products tasted like FOOD. This latest formulation-because it indeed was formulated by food "scientists" and created in a lab- is revolting.Its an oily, chemical-aftertaste mouthful of mush. There's no "butter" in the buttercreme(deliberately not spelled "cream" bc there's no cream!), no "crumb" to the cake, and I'm sickened not only after eating this poison, but by the knowledge that this corporation would actually manufacture something this terrible and put it on grocery store shelves!! Never again will I buy or eat anything peddled by your company-not even if you gave it away.
1 out of 5 stars
26 April, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
tastykake buttercream iced cupcakes
Got a box of the buttercreme cupkakes , what a disapointment!! the middle was sunken in and the icing was hard, it could be picked right off the top of the cake. Doesn't even taste that great!! will NOT be buying any of these products again!!! You should be ashamed to sell these!!
5 out of 5 stars
16 January, 2023
originally posted on tastykake
My Addiction
I know I have a problem, but these are the 1st packaged cupcake that I can want to eat the whole box. I fight the urge to want and indulge by eating every one. But normally when I can find them, 2 pack minimum per consumption. Love these!!!!!
1 out of 5 stars
14 November, 2022
originally posted on tastykake
I used to like these
Bought a box a couple weeks ago. Surprised at how white the icing was. Should be off white like pic on box. Tasted awful. Tossed in garbage. I was bummed. Won’t treat myself again. This change is gross.
1 out of 5 stars
2 October, 2022
originally posted on tastykake
MUCH SMALLER!
I’ve purchased my last box. These cupcakes are like two bite cupcakes. Like everything else shrinking size while price increases. Funny though, seems outside packaging hasn’t changed. Misleading so you think you’re purchasing what you’ve always had in the past. I’ll go back to baking my own.
5 out of 5 stars
29 May, 2022
originally posted on tastykake
BEST TASTING TASTYKAKE
Buttercreme Iced Cupcakes are so smooth and creamy when you bite into them. Try them you'll like them too.