Stila Stay All Day ArtiStix Micro Eyeliner - 0.002oz - Ulta Beauty

When I tried to apply this it was so hard. I had to mash it onto my eyelid so hard it would stretch it out. Made the area red. Like I really wanted it to work. Lovely fine point, but it's so physically hard. It would crumble under the pressure. I tried on a different day. Same thing. Used a warm humidifier-still couldn't soften it up. It just kept crumbling and not really transfering. Eventually I used the entire stick between TWO attempts.

Genuinely really difficult to use and it crumbles into pieces, you have to twist a thousand times to even get a bit out. When trying to use it a big chuck fell off and went into my eye and was a struggle to get out. If you apply to much pressure it will crumble but the product barley works without the pressure. Would not recommend.

I normally buy Stila all day smudge and wet gel liner and love it…but decided to try the stila ArtiStix micro eyeliner. HUGE MISTAKE and waste of money. 1. I had to turn it 100 times for the eyeliner to actually come out, at first i thought I received a defective eyeliner 2. I literally have to apply so much pressure to put it on just for it to crumble to pieces. 3. It literally just doesnt even work. So disappointed because stila usually has good eyeliner. Very upset because I depend on my eyeliner EVERYDAY.

I was having a hard time getting any pigment to transfer to my skin. I could see the eyeliner, definitely had enough exposed to apply, but I kept adjusting to have a bit more product come out, then the stick of product snapped off. It was crumbly when I tried to pick it up. I tried again to apply it and nothing still would stay on my skin. I painfully put enough pressure and finally got it on but never wanted to go through that again so I returned it. You can see in the pics the missing tip after it fell off.

I usually have eyeliner for a while and this barely lasted a month. Way to experience to only last that long. It didn’t go on very smoothly either. Will not be buying again.

The product stays all day and looks great on. Thats the trick is getting it on. You can't make small lines with the stuff. It will also break off in little pieces or sometimes big in your hand or onto the floor. I wouldn't recommend this for the price its not cheap and if it keeps breaking off I see it as a waste.

I wish I had read the other reviews before buying. I agree it is like trying to draw with mechanical pencil lead across your eyelid, and the result is a skipping, uneven line. I think a RoseArt crayon would have done a better job.

My usual Shiseido MicroLiner Ink Eyeliner was not available at Seph0ra at the time, so I gave this one a try from Ulta. Not impressed at all. First, it took way too many turnclicks to get the eyeliner tip out for first use and at the first swipe on my eyelid, a big chunk just broke right off. Eyeliner just didn't glide as smoothly as I would have liked. Felt very dry and kept tugging on my eyelid with every stroke. Definitely will have to go back to my usual Shiseido one.

SO hard to apply. It does not roll on smoothly like most other eyeliners I’ve used.

Horrible. Literally like using a #2 mechanical pencil on your eyes. It hurts to put on and breaks off constantly, so you lose three quarters of the $25 you pay for it.

Have been using Stila for a few years. Unfortunately, due to the packaging, bought the pencil instead of the liquid eye liner pencil. The pencil took many twists to come into use, then it broke off every time I used it. It didn't glide on it was dry and crumbly. Purchased L'oreal infallible instead. Disappointing.

Would not purchase again, it is like most gell eyeliner, difficult to apply . You should not press down to hard under the eye.

Does not twist at all. Completely defective product and should have read the other reviews saying the same thing.

What I love about this is that it stays on all day, and i've been searching for a waterproof gel eyeliner for my waterline that won't fade, or fade as quickly as the ones I've used. It is also super pigmented and goes on smoothly! However, what I hate about it is the fact that it breaks every time you twist it up. This is a perfect product other than that. If that could be fixed, this would be the best gel eyeliner in the world :) I hope this was helpful!

Goes on nice and thin, but even though the smallest amount possible is exposed from the pencil it often breaks. After only 3 weeks I cannot get any more to come out even though I can see there's more in pencil. Really disappointing as I liked it.

Would never buy again. I’ve tried this company twice, but have too many problems. Can’t recede the liner if you accidentally twist too much, not enough product for the price, and DOES NOT LAST.

Each time I rolled out the liner the top Breaks off the only way it didn't break was it was flush with the top and then it was difficult to apply.

Love the product but I've had difficulties with each of the three liners. Twisting to dispense the liner either requires several twists or over dispenses making it difficult to retract and makes it easy to break this wasting product.

I use this liner everyday. This is the perfect brown color! I finally found a precise liner that stays all day. Love!

I purchased this product thinking it was the liquid eyeliner from the Stila line. I love the liquid eyeliner because the application brush is similar to a paint brush marker which makes it easier and more accurate for me to apply. The Salesperson helped me pick this out either thinking the same thing, or she maybe thought that this particular eyeliner was what I was actually looking for. Regardless, I no longer use draw on eyeliners as they are usually too waxy and drag, they bleed, or break off easily. So this will be going back. Hopefully I can get the product I actually want.