New ArrivalsValentine’s DayClothing, Shoes & AccessoriesHomeKitchen & DiningGroceryHousehold EssentialsFurnitureOutdoor Living & GardenBabyToysVideo GamesElectronicsMovies, Music & BooksBeautyHealthPersonal CareGift IdeasParty SuppliesCharacter ShopSports & OutdoorsBackpacks & LuggageSchool & Office SuppliesPetsUlta Beauty at TargetShop by CommunityTarget OpticalGift CardsDealsClearanceTarget New ArrivalsValentine’s DayGalentine’s Day IdeasWomen’s Western OutfitsTop DealsTarget Circle DealsWeekly AdShop Order PickupShop Same Day DeliveryRegistryRedCardTarget CircleFind Stores
Target Circle™Target Circle™ CardTarget Circle 360™Registry & Wish ListWeekly AdFind Stores
Image

Get last-minute Valentine’s gifts fast

Get last-minute Valentine’s gifts fast

Get last-minute Valentine’s gifts fast

Use same-day delivery or Order Pickup to get candy, gifts & more.

Use same-day delivery or Order Pickup to get candy, gifts & more.

Use same-day delivery or Order Pickup to get candy, gifts & more.

peanut butter substitute

644 results

for “peanut butter substitute”

Oat Haus Cookie Dough Granola Butter - 12oz

$7.99($0.67/ounce)
Oat Haus Cookie Dough Granola Butter - 12oz
Oat Haus
(128)
Loved for: great taste
SNAP EBT eligible

LesserEvil Organic Popcorn Multipack Snacks Himalayan Gold - 3.68oz/8pk

$4.99($1.36/ounce)
LesserEvil Organic Popcorn Multipack Snacks Himalayan Gold - 3.68oz/8pk
LesserEvil
(461)
Loved for: great flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

RXBAR Minis Chocolate Sea Salt & Peanut Butter Chocolate Protein Bars - 7.36oz/8ct

$8.99($1.22/ounce)
reg $9.59
Sale
RXBAR Minis Chocolate Sea Salt & Peanut Butter Chocolate Protein Bars - 7.36oz/8ct
RXBAR
(114)
SNAP EBT eligible

RXBAR Protein Bars Energy Bites Chocolate Peanut Butter - 8.8oz/5ct

$9.59
RXBAR Protein Bars Energy Bites Chocolate Peanut Butter - 8.8oz/5ct
RXBARNew at target
(6)
SNAP EBT eligible

FitJoy Grain Free Pretzel Peanut Butter Nuggets - 5oz

$4.99
reg $5.99
Sale
FitJoy Grain Free Pretzel Peanut Butter Nuggets - 5oz
FitJoyNew at target
(35)
SNAP EBT eligible

Land O Lakes Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil

$3.99 - $6.49
Land O Lakes Spreadable Butter with Canola Oil
Land O'Lakes
(2949)
Loved for: rich flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Magic Spoon Marshmallow Treats - 5.6oz/4ct

18k+ bought in last month
$8.49($1.52/ounce)
reg $9.99
Sale
Magic Spoon Marshmallow Treats - 5.6oz/4ct
MAGIC SPOON
(837)
Loved for: great flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Smucker's Goober Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly Stripes - 18oz

$3.99($0.22/ounce)
Smucker's Goober Peanut Butter and Grape Jelly Stripes - 18oz
Smucker's
(618)
Loved for: Nostalgic flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Osem Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs - 4oz: Toddler Snack, 2nd Stage, Ready to Eat, Bag Container, Baby Snack

$2.99
Osem Bamba Peanut Butter Puffs - 4oz: Toddler Snack, 2nd Stage, Ready to Eat, Bag Container, Baby Snack
Osem
(887)
Loved for: great taste
SNAP EBT eligible

Sponsored

Mixed Nut Butter with Seeds - 12oz - Good & Gather™

$6.89($0.57/ounce)
Mixed Nut Butter with Seeds - 12oz - Good & Gather™
Good & GatherOnly at target
(75)
Loved for: great flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Purely Elizabeth Vanilla Almond Butter Grain Free Granola - 8oz

$6.49($0.81/ounce)
Purely Elizabeth Vanilla Almond Butter Grain Free Granola - 8oz
purely elizabeth.
(242)
Loved for: great flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

RXBAR High Protein Bars Vanilla Peanut Butter - 10.5oz/5ct

$8.99($0.86/ounce)
reg $9.59
Sale
RXBAR High Protein Bars Vanilla Peanut Butter - 10.5oz/5ct
RXBAR
(57)
SNAP EBT eligible

Oats Overnight Shake Chocolate Peanut Butter - 2.2oz

$3.19($1.45/ounce)
Oats Overnight Shake Chocolate Peanut Butter - 2.2oz
Oats Overnight
(175)
Loved for: convenient
SNAP EBT eligible

Legendary Foods Gluten Free and Keto Friendly Protein Pastry - S'mores - 8oz/4ct

$9.99($1.25/ounce)
Legendary Foods Gluten Free and Keto Friendly Protein Pastry - S'mores - 8oz/4ct
Legendary Foods
(240)
Loved for: great taste
SNAP EBT eligible

LesserEvil Organic Popcorn Himalayan Sea Salt - 4.6-oz

$3.19($0.69/ounce)
LesserEvil Organic Popcorn Himalayan Sea Salt - 4.6-oz
LesserEvil
(7598)
Loved for: great taste
SNAP EBT eligible

Variety Cookies - 16ct/22.4oz - Favorite Day™

$7.49($0.33/ounce)
Variety Cookies - 16ct/22.4oz - Favorite Day™
Favorite Day
(375)
Loved for: soft texture
SNAP EBT eligible

Bob's Red Mill 1 to 1 Gluten Free Baking Flour - 22oz

$5.29
Bob's Red Mill 1 to 1 Gluten Free Baking Flour - 22oz
Bob's Red Mill
(957)
Loved for: versatile
SNAP EBT eligible

Nature's Bakery Raspberry Fig Bar - 12oz/6ct

$4.29($0.36/ounce)
Nature's Bakery Raspberry Fig Bar - 12oz/6ct
Nature's Bakery
(2156)
SNAP EBT eligible

Yasso Frozen Greek Yogurt - Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Bars - 4pk/14 fl oz

$5.79($0.41/fluid ounce)
Yasso Frozen Greek Yogurt - Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Bars - 4pk/14 fl oz
Yasso
(167)
SNAP EBT eligible

KIND Peanut Butter Whole Grain Clusters Granola - 17oz

$6.99($0.41/ounce)
KIND Peanut Butter Whole Grain Clusters Granola - 17oz
KIND
(127)
Loved for: energy boost
SNAP EBT eligible

Sponsored

Get top deals, latest trends, and more.

Privacy policy

Footer

About Us

About TargetCareersNews & BlogTarget BrandsBullseye ShopSustainability & GovernancePress CenterAdvertise with UsInvestorsAffiliates & PartnersSuppliersTargetPlus

Help

Target HelpReturnsTrack OrdersRecallsContact UsFeedbackAccessibilitySecurity & FraudTeam Member ServicesLegal & Privacy

Stores

Find a StoreClinicPharmacyTarget OpticalMore In-Store Services

Services

Target Circle™Target Circle™ CardTarget Circle 360™Target AppRegistrySame Day DeliveryOrder PickupDrive UpFree 2-Day ShippingShipping & DeliveryMore Services
PinterestFacebookInstagramXYoutubeTiktokTermsCA Supply ChainPrivacy PolicyCA Privacy RightsYour Privacy ChoicesInterest Based AdsHealth Privacy Policy