Target New ArrivalsGift Ideas for MomClothing, Shoes & AccessoriesHome & DecorKitchen & DiningOutdoor Living & GardenGroceryHousehold EssentialsBabyBeautyPersonal CareHealthWellnessLuggageSports & OutdoorsToysElectronicsVideo GamesMovies, Music & BooksSchool & Office SuppliesParty SuppliesGift IdeasGift CardsPetsUlta Beauty at TargetShop by CommunityTarget OpticalDealsClearanceTarget New ArrivalsSpring OutfitsGift Ideas for MomWomen’s Festival OutfitsTop DealsTarget Circle DealsWeekly AdShop Order PickupShop Same Day DeliveryRegistryRedCardTarget CircleFind Stores
Target Circle™Target Circle™ CardTarget Circle 360™Registry & Wish ListWeekly AdFind Stores

peanut butter substitute

287 results for “peanut butter substitute”

Ground Up Snickerdoodle Almond & Cashew Butter Pouch - 1.15oz

$1.79($1.56/ounce)
Ground Up Snickerdoodle Almond & Cashew Butter Pouch - 1.15oz
Ground Up PDX
(35)
SNAP EBT eligible

Oat Haus Original Granola Butter Squeeze - 1.13oz

$1.49($1.32/ounce)
Oat Haus Original Granola Butter Squeeze - 1.13oz
Oat Haus
(14)
SNAP EBT eligible

SKIPPY P.B. Bites Girl Scouts Adventurefuls - 5.5oz

$3.99($0.73/ounce)
SKIPPY P.B. Bites Girl Scouts Adventurefuls - 5.5oz
Skippy
(312)
Loved for: delicious taste
SNAP EBT eligible

Redefine Foods Skippy Oatmeal Protein Pie Peanut Butter - 2.5oz

$2.99
Redefine Foods Skippy Oatmeal Protein Pie Peanut Butter - 2.5oz
Redefine FoodsNew at target
(2)
SNAP EBT eligible

Plant Based Organic Non-Dairy Buttery Spread - 13oz - Good & Gather™

$3.69($0.28/ounce)
Plant Based Organic Non-Dairy Buttery Spread - 13oz - Good & Gather™
Good & GatherOnly at target
(176)
SNAP EBT eligible

Plant Based Organic Non-Dairy Salted Buttery Sticks - 16oz/4ct - Good & Gather™

$4.29($0.27/ounce)
Plant Based Organic Non-Dairy Salted Buttery Sticks - 16oz/4ct - Good & Gather™
Good & GatherOnly at target
(100)
SNAP EBT eligible

Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Blend - 12oz

$8.49($0.71/ounce)
Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Blend - 12oz
Justin's
(222)
Loved for: rich flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Mighty Sesame Organic Tahini Squeezable - 10.9oz

$5.99($0.55/ounce)
Mighty Sesame Organic Tahini Squeezable - 10.9oz
Mighty Sesame Co.
(38)
SNAP EBT eligible

Earth Balance Organic Buttery Spread - 13oz

$4.29($0.33/ounce)
Earth Balance Organic Buttery Spread - 13oz
Earth Balance
(1)
SNAP EBT eligible

Justin's Cinnamon Almond Butter Pouch - 1.15oz

$1.49($1.30/ounce)
Justin's Cinnamon Almond Butter Pouch - 1.15oz
Justin's
(116)
Loved for: great flavor
SNAP EBT eligible

Sponsored

Smucker's Goober Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jelly Stripes - 18oz

$4.19($0.23/ounce)
Smucker's Goober Peanut Butter and Strawberry Jelly Stripes - 18oz
Smucker's
(224)
Loved for: Convenient packaging
SNAP EBT eligible

Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Blend - 1.15oz

$1.49($1.30/ounce)
Justin's Chocolate Hazelnut Butter Blend - 1.15oz
Justin's
SNAP EBT eligible

Bonne Maman Peanut Chocolate Spread - 12.3oz

$6.99($0.57/ounce)
Bonne Maman Peanut Chocolate Spread - 12.3oz
Bonne Maman
(8)
SNAP EBT eligible

MUSH Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Mini Protein Bars - 9.6oz/8ct

$8.49
MUSH Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Mini Protein Bars - 9.6oz/8ct
MushNew at target
(2)
SNAP EBT eligible

Justin's Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze - 1.15oz / 10ct

$9.99($0.87/ounce)
Justin's Classic Peanut Butter Squeeze - 1.15oz / 10ct
Justin's
SNAP EBT eligible

MUSH Chocolate Peanut Butter 15g Protein Overnight Oats - 5.5oz

$2.49
MUSH Chocolate Peanut Butter 15g Protein Overnight Oats - 5.5oz
MushNew at target
(1)
SNAP EBT eligible

Skippy Individual Squeeze Peanut Butter - 1.15oz / 8ct

$3.69($0.40/ounce)
Skippy Individual Squeeze Peanut Butter - 1.15oz / 8ct
Skippy
(4)
SNAP EBT eligible

Lily's Peanut Butter Baking Chips - 9oz

$8.99($1.00/ounce)
Lily's Peanut Butter Baking Chips - 9oz
Lily's Sweets
(663)
SNAP EBT eligible

Smash Foods Gluten Free Peanut Butter and Concord Grape Jammy Protein Bites - 5ct/1.8oz

$1.99($1.11/ounce)
reg $2.49
Sale
Smash Foods Gluten Free Peanut Butter and Concord Grape Jammy Protein Bites - 5ct/1.8oz
Smash Foods
(33)
SNAP EBT eligible

Sponsored

Get top deals, latest trends, and more.

Privacy policy

Footer

About Us

About TargetCareersNews & BlogTarget BrandsBullseye ShopSustainability & GovernancePress CenterAdvertise with UsInvestorsAffiliates & PartnersSuppliersTargetPlus

Help

Target HelpReturnsTrack OrdersRecallsContact UsFeedbackAccessibilitySecurity & FraudTeam Member ServicesLegal & Privacy

Stores

Find a StoreClinicPharmacyTarget OpticalMore In-Store Services

Services

Target Circle™Target Circle™ CardTarget Circle 360™Target AppRegistrySame Day DeliveryOrder PickupDrive UpFree 2-Day ShippingShipping & DeliveryMore Services
PinterestFacebookInstagramXYoutubeTiktokTermsCA Supply ChainPrivacy PolicyCA Privacy RightsYour Privacy ChoicesInterest Based AdsHealth Privacy Policy