MAC Color Excess Gel Eyeliner Pencil - 0.02oz - Ulta Beauty

I have been searching through so many products to find the perfect olive green shade for my brown eyes. This product is gorgeous, long lasting, and glides on smooth. This is a great product!

Excellent product , applies smoothly and stays on with out smudging- would highly recommend!

I’m not sure if I just ended up getting an old pencil, but I found this eyeliner to be difficult to apply. It does not go on smoothly like you would expect a gel pencil to do

Really good and long lasting. Performs well even on oily eyelids nd las all day without fading or smudging.

This is my forever eyeliner.. it's so pretty on dark brown eyes. It's the only eyeliner that doesn't smudge on me.

Not good

I have been using the techna Kohl and kajal liner from MAC for years. And for whatever reason they replaced it with this cheap gel liner. Even the tube it comes in seems cheap. It runs in the outer corners of my eyes and gets on my bottom lids. I only back line my lashes now because it's not good enough to work into Smokey eye liner. I now have to find alternatives because I'm fed up with the cheap products and the high prices Mac is still charging. Not to mention they closed the store closest to me so if I want to shop and not wait a week for shipping, I have to drive over an hour now. Ridiculous.

Expected more from MAC and this product. Even cut off the end to see if it would go on better. Difficult to line the eyes and disappeared in less than an hour.

I thought this would show up more purple but its actually quite dark on my fair skin. Because I have more mature skin i prefer somethign not black and this works really well, especially for my hazel eyes. Love the formula.

Love the formula, I wasnt expecting a coppery sheen but its perfect for my hazel eyes. It's a great alternative to dark brown.

I was looking for a cool toned bright lilac. I looked at the images shown for pale/light skin and it seemed to be just the thing. When i opened it it was much darker than advertised, not bright! You can see the true color in some pictures but the color advertised is misleading

It looks amazing with brown, dark brown, or black eyes, and it goes great with green or blue outfits too!

I love the color! It complements brown, dark brown, and black eyes perfectly. It also came off really easily.

This eyeliner glides on smooth and makes your eyes pop!

Is there a way to reconstitute this product because I had a blue one as well and they dry out with the lid on. I just don't get it.

These are super creamy, pigmented and once set don't budge. My only critique is that this shade doesn't apply as easily on the waterline. You have to give it a few passes.

Best eyeliner for sensitive eyes. Stays on all day

I purchased this in September. I had other eyeliners I was using. I used it for the first time today. I was disappointed that I couldn't get the pencil to glide easily. It was hard to get a line that looked good. Sadly, it's too late for me to return this.

my fav color - I had high expectations but I could not get it on dark enough

This eyeliner is so easy to work with and I love that its retractable. It feels smoother than a pencil but not as messy as liquid eyeliner. So easy to fix up any mistakes and I always get compliments!