Men's Shave Cream - 6.5 fl oz - Goodfellow & Co™

I tried this as a more affrodable option to Cremo, but it wasn't as good. It got the job done but never gave a great lather. I have since also tried Alba which is better as well.

This stuff is great! I don't think those giving it a negative review understand that it is meant to be used when you're taking a shower. This stuff is very very thin, but it is made to be washed away easily. I used this for the first time and it left my face clean and smooth. I also really love the sort of minty scent as well! It isn't like regular shaving cream/gel/shaving butter! It still works really well though and is made more for if you want a close shave! I definitely recommend it though, especially for the price!

The feeel was amazing and refreshing

Odd lingering smell. People complaining about not lather when the product clearly says it's a CREAM.

Way too runny, needs a thicker consistency. Does not lather up when you rub it on your face,. Good scent though.

Concept is a good idea, men's shave cream (not a foam) in a tube, but it's too runny and the annoying fragrance will stay with you for 24 hours, even if you wash your face afterwards. An Up & Up alternative to the discountinued Schick Hydro Sense Shave Cream in a tube would be appealilng.

I’m reviewing this because of the negative reviews it has gotten. 1) I have been a wet shaver for over 40 years. I’m talking real shaving and NOT with cartridges (expensive and worthless). My normal go to is Art of Shaving sandalwood cream, my brush and a Supply razor (shaved with Gillette adjustable razors for years, love the Supply). Now, in a pinch while traveling I purchased the Goodfellow and wasn’t sure what I’d get. Right, this cream does not lather. Not meant to lather, but I can see how someone could be misled. Long short of it, I was surprised. It did very well…better than some of my really expensive creams and soaps. Wet your face (or legs for the girls) and apply like a lotion. Point is…not a ton of water. Key ingredient in this cream is OLIVE OIL, which helps with the glide. Not sure what the folks are using to shave with that claim it’s the same as using water. If they are performing multiple passes then you may want to use a little to re-lubricate. It’s NOT expensive at all, so use it a bit liberally…but again, I was impressed with how it did. And IMO, Cremo is overpriced and does the same or worse than Goodfelllow. Remember, I was prepared to dislike this and give it a negative review. I cannot. And…will buy again to have it always on hand.

I didn't expect much from this, after using a European-sounding brand. I was amazed, my face, and head are both very smooth now. The scent was no too overpowering either. I will buy this again.

Got this for my boyfriend and he loved it! Great smell and great size

My husband loves this line so we decided to try out the shave cream. It’s a different consistency than any shave cream he’s used before it’s more of a lotion but he loves it. Gives a smooth shave & love the smell.

The only time I had to throw out a shave cream/lotion. It just did not lather and my face took a beating every time.

Almost no lather. Maybe half a step up from using warm water.

Smells great, just be cautious if you have sensitive skin. Gave me a slight burning sensation.

I started using this when Target stopped carrying the Neutrogena product. I like it. No negatives, pleasing fragrance, leaves my face feeling moisturized.

Used an entire tube before writing this. So much better than shave cream. Softens the beard well after rubbing on wet skin. It doesn't really lather like old fashion shave cream. It's more like a lotion that doesn't go away after applying. I started using a small amount ( the size of a hershey kiss) but by the end of the tube doubled that amount, which seems to work well. Found out I needed to apply more if I haven't shaved for 4-5 days.

This is the best shave cream I’ve ever used. It immediately softens my beard and lubricates my skin, so that shaving is quick and easy. I love it!

Thin. Virtually no lubrication. Abou the same as shaving with just water. Spend a couple bucks more for Cremo.

This is a great product that replaced a much more expensive one. It smells fantastic and my razor glides through it with no razor bumps. Great value at the price point and avoids a lot of chemicals I’d rather not put on my face!

This is a great brand. I normally use a diff brand but they were out so figured I’d try it. Was so good I never went back to my old brand. We’ve purchased this 3x now.

Doesn’t lather no matter how hard you try. Doesn’t work with a shave brush either, but it smells good. Pretty useless for shaving, better off with barbasol. Does the job perfectly.