Screamin' Sicilian Supreme Frozen Pizza - 25oz

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I lost control of my account for a bit. This pizza was as good as any frozen pizza I’ve had. I guess I’m not much of a pizza person. The box is flashy, no worries you’re buying the wrong thing. The toppings were kinda sparse, and lumped together, but easy enough to rearrange. Can you really call frozen pizza, ‘fresh’? It was fine in all honesty. A quick, easy weekend meal!

I bought this yesterday and cooked it last night. It made my entire house smell like chemicals, as if I was cleaning my oven. It never smelled like pizza. It kinda smelled like the box it came in. Its winter and I had to air my house out after cooking this pizza. It tasted OK, but even that is off. It had a sweet taste. I've had your pizza before and liked it. This was the first time I've had this particular flavor. I will not have it again. It smelled so awful, I have to wonder if it had fake meat or veggies in it. Is this what we have to look forward to? I hope not!

Once I bought one Supremus Maximus, I have found no ther that can compare!

The challenge for a store bought frozen pizza is the company is trying to appeal to a wide audience, AND cooking methods. This hits the mark very well IF you are willing to understand the challenges and be smarter than the average doofus who can't make popcorn in a microwave! Love this pie, but needs to do a "few" things for it to shine... - Take it out of the freezer for just a little bit to thaw, since the shipping will likely jostle the toppings around. Let this guy warm a LITTLE (not thawed) so you and evenly redistribute the great toppings! - I actually add bacon bits, anchovy and an extra light layer of mozzarella before baking. A drizzle of extra virgin olive oil and some basil (under the extra mozzarella) is also a GREAT tweak. - If you have it, use a convection oven at a lower temp (325) to cook until the top layer of cheese begins to melt/brown. - Pro finish- throw the baked pie into a perforated pizza baking pan and throw on the stove at med-low heat with (preferably) a gas flame! This will crisp the crust in the middle and if you only have an electric (or conduction) range, a foil tent will allow the crust to fully crisp with the toppings staying good and gooey! Yes, a big skillet (with a VERY light spray of olive oil) on the range will also work! The company may shoot my process down, but this bad boy is tops with a couple of tweaks!!!

Got my first one today. Saw advertisement on FB and decided to get the supreme. Loved it. Added more veggies and cheese to it but that's normal for me.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This pizza was perfect to throw right in the oven since the ingredients were frozen.pizza was large and came out looking so yummy. The weight in pizza you are gonna eat with this.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This was a yummy pizza with plenty of topping. Fed my family of 4 and we had a bit of leftover for the next day. The only thing was that it was a bit watery when it finished baking so I had to use some paper towels to soak up some of the water sitting on top of the pizza.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] this is probably my favorite pizza that i have ever bought.I LOVE THE TOPPINGS they are always so fresh and there after taste of all of there different options are also amazing would 10000000% recommend.

Just had my first screamin cheese pizza-WOW!! Delicious and great crust,thank you!!😋😁🥘

I purchased two (2) Supremus Maximus on 1/22/26 while they were on sale. I was looking for a different brand of supreme frozen pizza. so I tried Supremus Maximus for the first time. I loved the plentiful toppings of peppers, onion, olives and cheese. I did not like the taste of the sausage???, tomato sauce??, or stone-fired crust. What is a pizze without a great crust. The sausage and sauce lacked flavor (no or little Italian seasoning or olive oil. The crust was crunchy and tasted bland. Again, the toppings were plentiful.

LOVED ALL THE TOPPINGS, JUST THE RIGHT AMOUNT OF EVERYTHING, SO MANY FROZEN PIZZAS ARE SINGY WITH TOPPINGS, NOT YOURS!! THIS WILL BE A CONSTANT ON MY SHOPPING LIST! THE PRICE IS FABULOUS AND THE TASTE WAS EVEN BETTER! A SCREAMIN FAN FOREVER!

First time buy but not the last. Your supreme pizza is the best frozen pizza I have ever ate. I ate three pieces. I normally don’t eat but maybe one. Do you have savings coupons. I would highly recommend this Izzy. I have a loaded meat one in the freezer. Thank you.

Wow! The Screamin' Sicilian Maximus Supreme is the best frozen pizza I've ever had. Usually buy Jacks, Red Barron or Tombstone frozen pizzas to have on hand when ki don't feel like cooking. Saw this one and it looked good at a reasonable price so I thought I would try it. Glad I be did. This is my new go to frozen pizza I'll stock up my freezer with.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Screamin’ Sicilian has beautiful box, the pizza taste good enough for not having to do it myself and to have something quick and convenient. Will buy it again

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] Solid frozen pizza brand, first time trying it. It has good cheese coverage & good amount of even toppings between the pepperoni & the veggies. My only gripe was that I baked for the recommended time and while the outer crust was pretty toasty, the bottom of the pizza was still a little soft. I prefer a crispier bottom, but overall very good and my husband approved as well as our household frozen pizza connoisseur.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I cooked this on our Blackstone griddle while camping. It made the crust crispy and delicious. The meat was excellent and the pizza has great flavor. Will eat again!

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This pizza is so good. The first thing I noticed was the thick and fluffy crust. The cheese layer is bold and generous oozy mozzarella, and it’s topped with just enough pepperoni to keep every mouthful flavor-packed. I appreciated how the sauce is a perfect balance between tangy and savory. After baked, the crust that gets golden and crispy on the edges while staying soft in the middle. It’s rich and indulgent, so it makes a fantastic game night or movie night main event.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] very flavorful and so worth it! perfect movie date night dinner. very affordable as well, the combination of toppings was top notch! i definitely need to try the other flavors.

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This pizza is totally delicious! The price is reasonable. I love the crispiness. I followed the directions and it came out perfect for me. I love the packaging, it is full of graphics

[This review was collected as part of a promotion.] This pizza was hands down one of the best pizzas my family has had! There were many toppings on the pizza and the dough was also tasty! It was packaged well and we felt like a good value for what you got. The ratio of everything dough, sauce, cheese, toppings was perfect!