Reassessing Homer in the Platonic Tradition - (Beiträge Zur Altertumskunde) by Christina-Panagiota Manolea & François Renaud & Harold Tarrant

About the Book

Later antique writers admired both Plato and Homer. This volume concentrates on various responses to the Plato-Homer controversy on the part of Platonically minded writers, while including a few other reactions from just outside that circle. Strateg

Book Synopsis

Plato's famous and infamous criticism of Homer was the climax of a series of attacks by early thinkers on the first and greatest Greek poet Homer. It triggers an even longer series of responses attempting either to justify further "the old quarrel between philosophy poetry" (Pl. Resp. 607b-c), or, in most cases, to reconcile the two great authors. The so-called Plato-Homer problem is in broad outline twofold, with numberless ramifications and sub-issues. Why does Plato's Republic repeatedly attack and even exile the greatest cultural authority of the Greeks? And why does he do so while quoting Homer abundantly - more than any other author - and even adapting many artistic features of Homeric poetry? This volume concentrates on the various responses to the controversy among Platonically minded writers, while including a few other reactions from just outside that circle. Strategies of reconciliation are many, including both allegorical and non-allegorical approaches, involving the notions of myth, mimesis, inspiration, wisdom, theology, etc. The volume presents original treatments of major figures, such as Porphyry and Proclus, as well lesser-known authors or texts (e.g. Platonic Spuria), and non-Platonists (Xenophon, Aristotle, scholiasts, etc.) who serve as enlightening comparative figures. While recent literature on these questions usually concentrates on single authors, this book details its reception in the Platonic tradition overall.

About the Author

Christina-Panagiota Manolea, Hellenic Army Academy, Athens, Greece; François Renaud, Université de Moncton, Moncton, Canada; Harold Tarrant, University of Newcastle, Newcastle, Australia.