Reduced Fat Ice Cream - 16oz - Favorite Day™

Not sure why its called pecan pie- it taste like chocolate ice cream with 3 pecans. I want get this one again unless i want chocolate ice cream.

It's FABULOUS, but almost impossible to stop if you eat out of the carton. My flavor is listed in my Title.

Taste isn’t bad but the texture is just off and not very creamy. They are heading in the right direction, but I would stick to halo top for now.

Tastes amazing and for ice cream isn’t that unhealthy. Love it!

Incredible. Must buy. The mix ins are impeccable.

Love the smores where is this line going? I cannot find it anywhere at any store please say its not going out of business this is the best line we need more low calorie flavors

I LOVE this flavor and all of the other flavors of the reduced fat Favorite Day ice creams, besides the cookie dough. I wish our location would keep several flavors in stock, but they seem to only carry one flavor then no longer carry it. I would seriously buy cases of this stuff to keep on hand due to the awesome macros that fit within my goals. The texture is perfect, not chalky like some protein ice creams. I’m sad that our location keeps getting rid of the good flavors and hope to see them back soon!

10/10 no notes, the s’mores low calorie is the best low calorie high protein ice cream, the mix ins are amazing and the taste, texture and macros are better than halo top. If you ever stop making this I will find the recipe and start my own company to make this because it’s that good

Hands down the best light ice cream I’ve ever had! Please expand this line and add more flavors. I was in awe when I first tried the s’mores flavor. I just restocked my freezer today and can’t wait to pop one open this weekend! 😋

I Love the Mocha Cold Brew Coffee Ice Cream! It’s a bit hard to find in my area, please increase availability. The mild coffee flavor is great but the best part is the chocolate swirl, it tastes like ground up chocolate cookies with coffee nibs. I would buy it in bulk if I could-it’s really that good.

Really good alternative for the Fri night movie ice cream. We sometimes let it soften and then mix in a bit of protein powder. In this house, physique comes before dessert- with this, we have both.

I love this so much. Better tasting than halo top and the mix ins are so good!

The cookie dough one tastes too much like sugar alcohol and isn’t enjoyable. I would rather just not eat anything

Best s’mores ice cream ever. Tasted as delicious as Ben and Jerry’s and with so few calories. I’m obsessed. Started with the cold brew and love that flavor but wish it had more chocolate chips. The smores (only had one so far) had plenty of chocolate chips. It was soooo good!!!

favorite ice cream of all time!!

I didn't realize this was reduced-anything ice cream when I grabbed it (or when I began eating it). I just wanted mint-chocolate cookie ice cream and figured I would give this brand a try. I expected the typical mediocre quality ice cream, but was pleasantly surprised! First, the ice cream is white, not green. While an easy thing to manipulate, I personally find it's a sign of good quality when you don't need to color something to convince someone it is mint. This ice cream is not quite Haagen-Dasz-level quality, but probably second to it of the ones I have had. The flavour is really nice, the cookie chunks are good and well spread throughout, and it melts nicely. I only realized it was reduced-sugar when I figured it must be pretty high-calorie for how yummy how it was and checked the nutrition information. The only other indication is that when it freezes, it freezes HARD. But as mentioned, it melts nicely when you're ready to eat. Will buy again.

First time in last time trying this ice cream will save my money. Do not recommend.

Not terrible, but not great

The picture on the curtain looks great, but don’t be fooled. I was expecting chunks of chocolate and chunks of cookie dough. There was literally one (yes, one) chunk of cookie dough in this. What a letdown. Plenty of chocolate chunks but ultimately this should just be called chocolate chunk ice cream. I’ll stick with Halo Top.

I just opened my Favorite Day chocolate peanut butter ice cream and it's almost half empty. What a joke and disappointment. I won’t be buying this brand again!