$4.79 ($0.30/ounce)
In Stock
Eligible for registries and wish lists
At a glance
About this item
Additional product information and recommendations
Frequently bought together
Related Categories
Guests are saying
This peanut butter has garnered mixed reviews, with many guests praising its natural ingredients and rich peanut flavor. The glass jar packaging is a highlight, appealing to those seeking healthier options without added sugars or oils. However, some guests have expressed concerns about the texture, describing it as gritty or too oily. Overall, it remains a popular choice for those who appreciate a more authentic peanut butter experience.
Summary created by AI from text of reviews reflecting recent feedback provided across different star ratings (includes incentivized reviews)
4.3 out of 5 stars with 896 reviews
quality: 4.35 out of 5
taste: 4.4 out of 5
value: 4.35 out of 5
78% would recommend
70 recommendations
1 out of 5 stars
5 February, 2026
originally posted on Smucker's
Out with new back to the old
I bought this as a healthier option, but it didn’t come with a warning label as I try to make a sandwich as I walked out the door just opening up this jar oil splattered all over my work clothes my brand new pants disgusting supposed to be a healthier option usually by Skippy, but I thought this would be better,disappointing
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 4 days ago
We’re sorry to hear about this, and we appreciate you bringing it to our attention. The lid on our Smucker’s Creamy Natural Peanut Butter does mention that oil separation is normal for this product; however, this still isn’t the experience we want you to have with our products. To learn more and better assist you, we’ve reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
1 out of 5 stars
2 February, 2026
originally posted on Smucker's
Store brand peanut butter tastes better than this.
It is so runny and gritty. And if that wasn't bad enough the worst is the taste. It is the nastiest peanut butter I have ever had! I would rather buy store brand peanut butter. Smuckers peanut butter used to be my favorite one but not now.
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 6 days ago
Thank you for bringing this to our attention, this isn't the quality we expect, nor the experience we want you to have with our products. So we can learn more and best help, we have reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
1 out of 5 stars
2 February, 2026
originally posted on Smucker's
Disappointed
I thought I'd try this. Not a fan. It is not creamy-its gritty, runny and slimy no matter how much you stir it. Learned my lesson- stick with what you know.
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 6 days ago
Thank you for bringing this to our attention, this isn't the quality we expect, nor the experience we want you to have with our products. So we can learn more and best help, we have reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
5 out of 5 stars
24 January, 2026
originally posted on Smucker's
New consumer
New consumer of Smuckers Natural peanut butter and our entire household all rave about the taste, consistency and the glass jar! We reuse the jar vs recycling. Thanks for providing a healthy alternative.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
11 January, 2026Verified purchase
Delicious
By far the tastiest of the natural peanut butters.
4 out of 5 stars
31 December, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Wider and Shallower Jar
I like the product, but ease of use for consumers would improve if you used a wider and shallower jar. Such an 18 oz. jar with 16 oz of product would be easy to stir, removing a messy impediment to purchasing this product. You'd probably sell more.
5 out of 5 stars
20 December, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Favorite for years
We have been buying this peanut butter for years. Nothing but a little salt added. Perfection.
1 out of 5 stars
3 December, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Very disappointing
I’ve been trying to stay away from sugars and palm oil in peanut butter. Some of the organic naturals, though, aren’t the greatest when it comes to taste. I also wanted glass packaging so I could recycle when finished. So, I thought I’d go with Smuckers since that’s my jam and jelly of choice. Wow! Was I disappointed! Even after emptying the jar to give it a thorough stir, it was still incredibly runny. Plus, I bought creamy but the peanut butter was full of gritty pieces of nut. That’s why I abandoned almond butter - that grittiness. Overall, this was a complete disappointment. The entire jar ended up in my trash because I didn’t want to spend any more time on emptying it and washing the jar to recycle.
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 1 month ago
Thank you for bringing this to our attention, this isn't the quality we expect, nor the experience we want you to have with our products. So we can learn more and best help, we have reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
2 out of 5 stars
Thumbs down graphic, would not recommend
21 November, 2025Verified purchase
Awful!
Good price. BUT, Smuckers let me down on this product. It's gritty, even after stirring. And, it tastes dry and horrid. I also purchased the Good and Gather natural creamy and it tastes great. I am shocked Smuckers did a terrible job on this peanut butter aka peanut putty.
4 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
11 November, 2025Verified purchase
I have got crunchy in a creamy jar!
I used to use this brand for couple years and love it! It just peanuts & salt. Oil separation is a sign for natural peanut spread, my recommendation is to store it upside down. My last jar was confusing, I got crunchy peanut butter texture in a jar that says (Creamy), very disappointing.
5 out of 5 stars
Thumbs up graphic, would recommend
11 November, 2025Verified purchase
Our go to peanut butter
We love this peanut butter as a natural alternative to the ones with sugar and other added ingredients. This simply has peanuts and a touch of salt. It is a bit of a pain to initially stir, I recommend a heavy duty knife or something. After that, it is much easier to stir. With it being just peanuts and salt, it does have a runny and gritty texture. Some people may not like that.
4 out of 5 stars
9 November, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Refrigerate or not
I always purchase Smucker's Natural peanut butter. After opening, should it be refrigerated? After in the frig it becomes hard to spread.
5 out of 5 stars
9 November, 2025Verified purchase
PB
Daughter loves it
5 out of 5 stars
4 November, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Smucker's Regular Creamy and Sucker Natural diff
Reading the reviews people seem to be getting Smucker's Regular Creamy and Sucker Natural confused. Natural does not have the other oils and is less finally ground but has no other seed oils. Great Product!!!
2 out of 5 stars
1 November, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
NOT A QUALITY PRODUCT LIKE IN THE PAST !
Your peanut butter is inconsistent either to much oil or almost none . I also just got a piece of metal in mine. I almost swallowed it but detected it when I bit down. That’s a lawsuit waiting to happen. I’m very disappointed with the quality of, I’ve had to throw away brand new jars because the freshness was nonexistent. Please give me a reason to keep buying your now very expensive low quality product?
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 3 months ago
We're sorry to hear this, as this is never the experience we want anyone to have with our products. To help us learn more and assist you best, please call us at 888-550-9555, Monday to Friday, 8 AM – 5 PM EST. Additionally, we’ve reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
2 out of 5 stars
27 October, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Disappointed
I use Smuckers creamy forever. Lately it’s been gritty, hard to stir, and less oil. I hope you will be changing it bacob to previous product.
1 reply from Consumer Relations team - 3 months ago
Thank you for bringing this to our attention, this isn't the quality we expect, nor the experience we want you to have with our products. So we can learn more and best help, we have reached out to you directly via email. We look forward to connecting with you soon.
5 out of 5 stars
26 October, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Simply the best peanut butter
Excellent peanut butter, the simple 2 ingredients drew my attention immediately. Simple clean whole food!
1 out of 5 stars
14 October, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Not Creamy
I just tried this and was VERY DISAPPOINTED because it is not creamy. It is full of very small pieces of peanuts and peanut skins. It has a nice taste but it Smuckers doesn’t know the definition of creamy.
1 reply from consumer team - 4 months ago
Thank you for your feedback. Please know that Natural Peanut Butter cannot be ground as finely as stabilized peanut butters. We want to assure you that our products are made with the best quality ingredients available and by the most carefully controlled procedures in the food industry. We appreciate the opportunity to receive your honest feedback and have reached out to you via email, so we may learn more and to best help.
1 out of 5 stars
11 October, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Old Favorite, not any more!
We have been using your Creamy Natural Peanut Butter since it came on the market. The last two jars have been full of “peanut” confetti😡. If I wanted chunky I would have purchased chunky for myself, as I do for my husband. You have changed your process or processor and have ruined your product.
1 reply from consumer team - 4 months ago
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter over the years. However, we are sorry to hear about the issue you experienced with your recent purchases, as this certainly does not reflect our quality standards. Please know that we value the opportunity to receive your honest feedback and will share your experience with our team. We are also reaching out to you via email to learn more about your experience and to assist you further. We look forward to connecting with you soon!
1 out of 5 stars
5 October, 2025
originally posted on Smucker's
Bits of Peanuts
We don’t care for the bits of peanuts in it. When you buy creamy peanut butter, you don’t expect to taste bits of peanuts.
1 reply from consumer team - 4 months ago
Thank you for your feedback. Please know that Natural Peanut Butter cannot be ground as finely as stabilized peanut butters. We want to assure you that our products are made with the best quality ingredients available and by the most carefully controlled procedures in the food industry. We appreciate the opportunity to receive your honest feedback and have reached out to you via email, so we may learn more and to best help.