The Tolerance Generation - by Sarah Miller (Paperback)

Book Synopsis

Draws directly on insights from teens to reframe our understanding of bullying in the age of social media and why anti-bullying campaigns have been unsuccessful in combating it.

Fitting in and standing out is an eternal rite of passage for teenagers. Increasingly, their struggles to establish hierarchies and regulate social norms are labeled under the umbrella of "bullying." This phenomenon is considered such a significant problem that all fifty states have passed anti-bullying legislation, and many schools now engage prevention programs that promote tolerance, kindness, and active bystander interventions. Despite these efforts, bullying remains as widespread as ever. Why is that? The answer lies in a unique challenge faced by teens today: social media.

In The Tolerance Generation, sociologist Sarah Miller explores how youth grapple with bullying in the digital age alongside the anti-bullying industry. Drawing on two school years with students at a Northeastern high school, Miller reveals how institutional efforts to curb bullying are no match for the many online interactions in which bullying thrives. She charts teens' experiences as they confront not only bullying, but also sexting exposures, school shooting threats, and viral cancel culture, illustrating the escalating pressures social media places on youth. Yet the school's anti-bullying campaigns are a mismatch. They are engineered to address individual instances of explicit conflict, not to change the culture that contributes to bullying, nor to help marginalized students who are most likely to be targeted. Miller captures how exclusion and harm spread through the interplay of teens' on and offline lives and shows how this is due, in part, to school practices that both reinforce--and fail to address--bullying as a systemic problem.

But while social media can foster conflict, it can also be a tool for building a youth culture of care. Miller shows how many teens harness digital culture to develop their own prevention strategies, going beyond tolerance to use social media as a site for education, conflict resolution, and resistance. Ultimately, Miller argues that the anti-bullying movement is an inadequate training ground for youth to learn how to deal with American inequalities. However, by addressing the structural factors that produce bullying, and by listening to teens' wisdom on how best to handle it, schools can create a more effective curriculum.

Review Quotes

"The Tolerance Generation is an urgent critique of the anti-bullying industry. Miller shows us that while adults were busy teaching 'niceness, ' students were busy building digital counter-publics to survive a school culture that values the performance of tolerance over the pursuit of justice. It is a foundational text for understanding youth culture and schools today."

"The Tolerance Generation makes an important contribution to understanding the lives of young people by focusing on their experiences with bullying and schools' efforts to take this more seriously. Miller's rich ethnographic account reveals the ways youth engage in, resist, and make sense of bullying as well as how schools respond to this with anti-bully programming. Miller offers a thought-provoking sociological analysis that complicates how we think about the digital lives of youth, conflict between them, and the role that schools play in addressing and producing bullying among students. The Tolerance Generation pushes us to consider what happens when we fail to account for the various inequalities youth grapple with in and outside of school in designing and implementing school anti-bullying programming."

About the Author